Who would you drop?

[Ant2611]

1 mbye
2 bmoz
3jmoz
4 olive
5 holland
6 Foran
7 Frawley
8 woods
9 famanu brown
10 klemmer
11 RFM
12 Rhys Martin
13 jj
14 jmk
15 Eastwood
16 renof t
17 Finee

I also think this is the best team we could have at the moment

 

[Vek]

Agree with most of what you said.
I would definitely move JMK to 9.
Not sure who to 6? Lewis or Frawley not sure who.

I have never been a fan of Lichaa, he has the worst passing game from DH in the NRL.
Great defensive player.
Some good darts from dummy half.
But overall he holds the team back.

I like lichaa too, problem is he blamed des for his lack of running out of dummy half, yet here is now still playing the same. I generally dont like to jump in and pick on players and blame 1 player, but everyone was putting in effort against the roosters attack wise, and our poor organisation from 9 ruined our attack.

I think for the 6/7 combo, Frawley/Foran might be a good choice, as Frawley played a lot of first grade already, and has shown he is good in attack. Since the rest of the team is defending well, I think he could do well in the 6 with JMK giving the running/passing, even kicking (which Lichaa doesnt have) in the 9 position. We could have Lichaa on the bench to come in and add that solid defence once we have a good lead, but again I would prefer that bench spot used by To'omaga as I think he is a gun player.

 

[jasonsmith11]

remember lichaa has till round 23 to turn things around, we should go back and see what people here said about lichaa getting a new contract and then see what i said

 

[hulk hogan]

Licha licha licha all day hopeless barely a 1st grade
Elliot rubbish same as licha
Might as well bring Frawley back jMK to hooker what do we have to lose anyway semis are gooooonnee

 

[yearofthedogs2018]

Am I the only one who still has faith in Tualau? Yes, he had a bad game this year but last year he did his job off the bench and performed well. He provides good metres and impact and we have to remember the circumstances in that game where he was having to play a lot longer minutes than he is used to.

I definetely want to see Ogden, To’omaga and possibly Martin given a go but I still believe there is a spot for Tualau.

I wouldn’t mind seeing this team
1. Mbye
2. Bmoz
3. Jmoz
4. Olive
5. Hoppa
6. Lewis/Brown/JMK
7. Foran
8. Woods
9. Brown/JMK
10. Klemmer
11. Fine/Martin
12. RFM
13. Jackson
14. Tualau
15. Fualalo/Ogden
16. To’omaga
17. Brown/Lewis/Fine/Martin (depends whether you want utility or edge player)

 

[yearofthedogs2018]

Montoya, Hopa, Elliott, Fualalo, Fine and Holland should all be dropped

sorry what has fine done wrong in his short stint?

Yes there is better players out there of course but he is young with speed and footwork and hasn’t done much wrong so far. He is trying.

 

[KLil]

I'd rather find out why the dogs performance was so lethargic... If there is no excuse then i'd drop 2 big personalities not putting 100% in.

1 would be Mbye for deciding to kick a massive spiral bomb with 6 min to go after shocking kicks all game and a tired as fuck performance.

2 would be a Klemmer, big name forward that nobody would expect to get dropped..

If that doesn't change attitudes then nothing will.

 

[KLil]

Fualalo needs to free a bench spot up

Fualalo is good for one thing and one thing only... 20mins of just barging forward, He adds nothing else.

 

[Dingo]

Fualalo is good for one thing and one thing only... 20mins of just barging forward, He adds nothing else.

He adds a couple of errors usually

 

[billy bulldog]

I would drop three players Elliot to much mistakes in his game licaa is the key to our attack and he needs a wheelchair and hopa is on the same track they both need a hospital bed

 

[billy bulldog]

Licaa is at best nsw cup his to slow

 

[billy bulldog]

As long as we have him in the team we won’t beat the top teams we need a rocket out of dummy half so our fowards and backs can get a roll on by 15 mins his huffing and puffing not up to first grade standard never was

 

[ibby]

Drop licha 100%

 

[ibby]

And also drop the whole team

 

[billy bulldog]

If I was the coach this would be my team

 

[billy bulldog]

Moses mybe
Brett Morris
Josh morris
Reece Martin
Marcolo Montaya
Josh Cleveland
Kieron Foran
Arron woods
Jeremy Marshall king
David Klemmer
Josh Jackson
Raymond fatiler mariner
Greg Eastwood
Nu brown
Danny fualo
Adam Elliott
Francis tualo

 

[coach]

I'd rather find out why the dogs performance was so lethargic... If there is no excuse then i'd drop 2 big personalities not putting 100% in.

1 would be Mbye for deciding to kick a massive spiral bomb with 6 min to go after shocking kicks all game and a tired as fuck performance.

2 would be a Klemmer, big name forward that nobody would expect to get dropped..

If that doesn't change attitudes then nothing will.

So ur dropping mbye one of our best over opening rounds, ran over 200 metres and klemmer who also ran over 200 metres with 20 odd hitups and nearly 30 tackles.......
Sit back on the lounge!
Just to change attitudes of underperforming players .....
Smart man....

 

[coach]

Moses mybe
Brett Morris
Josh morris
Reece Martin
Marcolo Montaya
Josh Cleveland
Kieron Foran
Arron woods
Jeremy Marshall king
David Klemmer
Josh Jackson
Raymond fatiler mariner
Greg Eastwood
Nu brown
Danny fualo
Adam Elliott
Francis tualo

Martin in centres?
Cleeland? Obviously haven't watched isp, ask anyone who watches isp on their opinion on cleeland this year....

 

[Spoonman84]

You can’t say drop because he’s injured but we haven’t missed anything with Tolman being out if anything the defence has looked better in the games he’s missed. Hopefully a team is still keen to take him and free up some salary cap space.

 

[KLil]

He adds a couple of errors usually

Bit harsh the other night.. That was a blatant rake.