Opinion Sivo try

[belmontdog]

The pass was 3 metres forward

 

[Chris Harding]

The pass was 3 metres forward

Looked OK to me.

 

[AlzzBulldog]

The pass was 3 metres forward

Their first try was forward

 

[ricko_29]

Ball did travel forward, but it was back out of the hands, good try.

 

[04 Dreaming]

The pass was 3 metres forward

You’re blind as a bat. Should sign up to become a ref

 

[Hacky McAxe]

Their first try was forward

Definitely forward. If they were running backwards then they wouldn't get over the try line.

 

[belmontdog]

You’re blind as a bat. Should sign up to become a ref

Dreaming mmm that says it all

 

[kaluah8123]

The pass was 3 metres forward

Floated 2m forward

 

[DOGSOFWAR2013]

Forward. Threw it behind the line. Sivo catches it infront of the 10m line.
No try .

 

[flamebouyant]

The pass was 3 metres forward

Yep

 

[flamebouyant]

Ball did travel forward, but it was back out of the hands, good try.

No it wasnt.

 

[B-Train]

I didn't think it was that bad but either way they would have won easily. If Parra weren't so shit, they would have won by 60, we were that bad today..

 

[Doggystyle99]

Forward. Threw it behind the line. Sivo catches it infront of the 10m line.
No try .

Id have to look at it again but that’s not necessarily the best way to judge a pass. If you throw it backwards but are running at full pelt, inertia can make the ball travel forward. As long as it’s back out of the hands it doesn’t matter how far afterwards it travels forward. Funny thing is I don’t even think the refs know this lol.

 

[Doogie]

50/50 on the forward pass given the way forward passes are these days - not a biggie. More worried about the disallowed try in the 1st half. The pass was on the line and bounced forward - should have been play on - but thats cool - we have a bunker apparently.

But the play the ball for the Sivo try had no foot involved. Shame the 'bunker' missed that one.

 

[KLil]

The almost intercept by Okunbor was going to be atleast 5m forward... wish he let that go.,

 

[BankstownBulldog]

I had my fair share of carlton dry’s before this try but I thought it was an obvious forward pass.

I didn’t feel like the momentum contributed to how far forward it was.

 

[Philmus]

would it have changed the outcome? no? then why post this? permaban

 

[J_Cooper]

I can’t believe there’s ppl here defending parra. Not only was that pass forward they had another 4-5 not picked up from dummy half if not more. Yet Reed throws one flat and it’s picked up straight away

 

[enoughsaid]

look foward live at the game