I don't hate it. Costs us nothing, yet "the Grub" being back in Belmore will make fans happy, and he will provide value to the club/players around him in terms of the pride, passion and effort he brings around the training paddock.
On top of that, he will only be top 30 if he's good enough and earns his way in, same for our starting 17.
I doubt he has the organisational skills we need for HB, but he can at the very least draw and pass better than Flanagan, and has a running game, which would be a net positive on our current attack. *shrugs* The only downsides could be if he takes the spot away from someone we like, which doesn't seem to be the case currently, or if he plays for us and resumes tripping and doing dumb shit on the field. But I can't imagine Ciraldo risking his coaching career by feeling pressured to include him and play him in spite of the club's best interests, right?