beastwood89
Kennel Enthusiast
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2013
- Messages
- 1,810
- Reaction score
- 2,984
Whare has been released by the panthers to join Catalans effective immediately
The last resort !So they’ve come to the media
I wouldn't give them shit even if it means no Burton this year. Stuff them.I would give them wakeham ,Napa or Nick meaney I feel that's fair enough
Spot on.Well technically he’s not in blue and white yet and by the sounds of it it’s still not a done deal. And you did disappear when the Burton situation went a little quiet and returned as soon as something hit the news. So I don’t blame everyone for thinking you were making shit up
Youll be eating your words on this one brudah... Kid will be one of the best halves in the league one day if not the best.Burton is better but overhyped imo. If he was playing for us last year he would've been smashed on here. Won't be as easy playing behind our pack when compared to Panthers.
Eat what words? I said he was overhyped, that doesn't mean I don't rate him.Youll be eating your words on this one brudah... Kid will be one of the best halves in the league one day if not the best.
Definitely not overhyped.Eat what words? I said he was overhyped, that doesn't mean I don't rate him.
Penrith wanted a swap for a players that we wouldn't release to themGoing to the media does sound like a last resort but it's a good option IMO because now everybody at Penrith knows he's unhappy and wants out. They can't BS anymore and tell themselves he's happy playing CC for 22/25 games or that he's happy at Penrith because he'll develop better under Cleary
Burton is class though. He's a cut above most halves and looked better than Luai and was the dominant half in the games they played together last year. That's saying something considering how impressive Luai was.Burton is better but overhyped imo. If he was playing for us last year he would've been smashed on here. Won't be as easy playing behind our pack when compared to Panthers.
Can you say who it was they wanted now??Penrith wanted a swap for a players that we wouldn't release to them
So they chuck a tantrum
Ok just to be clear on why Burton is surplus to Penriths needs and let’s just pretend hypothetically that Cleary and Luai are picked in the halves for NSW which is very doubtful both are they will have:I wouldn't even say it's sour grapes from Cleary. There's a chance that come origin time they'll need Burton even If injuries to their halves doesn't push him into the side sooner. Both their halves have been pushing for rep selection, so it's not beyond possible that they'll both get called up this year. It's like expecting someone to give you their spare tyre because you didn't get your flat tyre fixed. You may not need that spare tyre, but maybe you will. Could be the difference between pushing for the top four for them this year.
That's awkwardOk just to be clear on why Burton is surplus to Penriths needs and let’s just pretend hypothetically that Cleary and Luai are picked in the halves for NSW which is very doubtful both are they will have:
Tyrone May and Jaemen Salmon to cover them!
and in the very unlikely case that both Penrith centres in Crighton and Naden are both selected they will have:
Paul Momirovski and Dean Whare to cover them!
Mate if you are going to argue a point for Cleary then at the very least do yourself a favor and research into Penriths player depth and experience before mouthing off because you just come off like an uniformed twat! In other words don’t just argue for the sake of argument ok, thanks bud.
He is overhyped.Definitely not overhyped.