Opinion Ash Taylor or Mitchell Pearce

[David holland]

To get around the park we need a 7,
Release a back so Averillo can fit in there somewhere and I'd be happy with the Roster

 

[Freakzilla]

Not Ashley Taylor. Don't want him near our club.

 

[Bulldog1966]

NEITHER..how many times are these shithouse options going to be thrown up...makes me wanna....well throw up

 

[bradyk]

Pearce, but neither.

 

[Dingo]

Both suck.

 

[Noeasyday]

Hi David

 

[Abdul..]

Neither

 

[Bulldogsteve]

can mods just delete these stupid repetitive posts, same shit every day

 

[Noeasyday]

can mods just delete these stupid repetitive posts, same shit every day

Personally, I'd be lost without Dave's insightful posts

 

[Bulldogsteve]

Personally, I'd be lost without Dave's insightful posts

he posts the same shit on facebook and then repeats on here, very painful.

 

[JORDZILLA]

Taylor is a Kyle Flanno

 

[c-b-b]

If we're talking shit options why not include Lukey Brooks.

 

[COVENS]

If we're talking shit options why not include Lukey Brooks.

People laugh but he's legitimately the 6th-8th best halfback in the comp, which by my count is better then the worst halfback in the comp. Count it out:
1. Cleary
2. Hughes
3. DCE
4. Reynolds
5. Moses
6. Walker

Then who?

 

[Dogsville]

no thanks to both. i'd rather give BBO a chance, yes an experienced half would be good but not Pearce.

 

[Bulldog1966]

People laugh but he's legitimately the 6th-8th best halfback in the comp, which by my count is better then the worst halfback in the comp. Count it out:
1. Cleary
2. Hughes
3. DCE
4. Reynolds
5. Moses
6. Walker

Then who?

Hunt, Johnson, Pearce(a bit better)but you have a point after that is maybe around 10th "best" but still wouldn't entertain any of these.Taylor isn't the right fit even if he was good enough.

 

[c-b-b]

People laugh but he's legitimately the 6th-8th best halfback in the comp, which by my count is better then the worst halfback in the comp. Count it out:
1. Cleary
2. Hughes
3. DCE
4. Reynolds
5. Moses
6. Walker

Then who?

I'd have Shaun Johnson and Pearce ahead and maybe Fogarty on par. He's on close to 850k next year, any club looking to take him on would need to pick up a big chunk of that.

 

[bradyk]

People laugh but he's legitimately the 6th-8th best halfback in the comp, which by my count is better then the worst halfback in the comp. Count it out:
1. Cleary
2. Hughes
3. DCE
4. Reynolds
5. Moses
6. Walker

Then who?

1. Cleary
2. Hughes
3. DCE
4. Reynolds
5. Moses
6. Hunt
7. Johnson
8. Fogarty
9. Pearce
10. Townsend
11. Brooks
12. Taylor

S. Walker behind Lam and Hutchison atm so hard to place him. On potential (and shown a fair bit this year to be fair) S. Walker's around Moses. I probably wouldn't take anyone under Fogarty to replace Averillo at halfback either which basically means we can't get a better option all things considered.

 

[Bulldogsteve]

I'd have Shaun Johnson and Pearce ahead and maybe Fogarty on par. He's on close to 850k next year, any club looking to take him on would need to pick up a big chunk of that.

Pearce is too slow now, he killed the newcastle attack on the weekend. Ponga needs it first off the ruck not out the fukn back.
Taylor is a 6, he doesnt handle the pressure of a 7.
IMO none of the above are better than Averillo or have a higher ceiling than Averillo.

 

[utility half]

If we sign Pearce after sacking Elliott for bad behaviour, I will riot.

 

[Noeasyday]

he posts the same shit on facebook and then repeats on here, very painful.

Are you friends with Dave on Facebook?