Opinion Ash Taylor or Mitchell Pearce

[steveng]

None

 

[TwinTurbo]

Is there a meme that is the opposite of the "why not both?" meme?

Always a Bulldog

 

[CroydonDog]

Tbf, I wouldn't be prepared to write off Ash Taylor's career just yet, after all that potential he showed.

Obviously needs a complete overhaul. New club would be good for him.

You would want him cheap though.

 

[Waldo]

Neither they both suck ass

 

[Bulldogsteve]

Tbf, I wouldn't be prepared to write off Ash Taylor's career just yet, after all that potential he showed.

Obviously needs a complete overhaul. New club would be good for him.

You would want him cheap though.

i agree but he is a 6 not a 7, cant handle the pressure at 7

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Tbf, I wouldn't be prepared to write off Ash Taylor's career just yet, after all that potential he showed.

Obviously needs a complete overhaul. New club would be good for him.

You would want him cheap though.

We are not that club, probably.

 

[Riggs80]

Apparently wherever Pearce signs there is a ban on owning dogs within 30km of his house for their protection

so would the club have to get rid of the mascot and change names if he signed ?

 

[BlackDawg]

Mate taylor only plays rugby league for a cheque just like Simms. They don't give a fuck if they win or lose at club level. Pearce may be 32 and he may be a fuckwit off the paddock but the bloke at least puts in at club level. Personally I don't think either will come to the club more because I think Gould will sit back & see who performs week in week out in next year's 30 man roster in 2022 and continue to build promising juniors. It will then become clearer what we truely need for 23. I think next year will be Dufty FB, averillo & burton halves & Cook/JMK hooker. that means 2022 is a 9 to 12 finish but our roster will start looking way more refined in 2023 & hopefully we actually get some exciting juniors start filtering into 1st grade as a bonus.

 

[chisdog]

so would the club have to get rid of the mascot and change names if he signed ?

yep or provide Pearce with protection.

 

[dogbone]

Mate taylor only plays rugby league for a cheque just like Simms. They don't give a fuck if they win or lose at club level. Pearce may be 32 and he may be a fuckwit off the paddock but the bloke at least puts in at club level. Personally I don't think either will come to the club more because I think Gould will sit back & see who performs week in week out in next year's 30 man roster in 2022 and continue to build promising juniors. It will then become clearer what we truely need for 23. I think next year will be Dufty FB, averillo & burton halves & Cook/JMK hooker. that means 2022 is a 9 to 12 finish but our roster will start looking way more refined in 2023 & hopefully we actually get some exciting juniors start filtering into 1st grade as a bonus.

So basically GF in 2024? The prophecy is true.
1974 lost, 84 won, 94 lost, 2004 won, 2014 lost, 2024 ???

 

[The__GM]

No to both.

 

[bricktamland]

I don’t care what anyone says ash Taylor on his day is solid ! Great kicking game but has no mongrel or defence. Definitely a confidence player unfortunately

 

[bricktamland]

I’m happy to give bbo the job he’s speedy full of potential

 

[finchie]

Been told last night Gus is meeting with James seggyaro for a train and trial contract over the summer
Would most likely be second tier $80k-$110k only
And doesn’t take a spot from the fulltime roster

 

[Mitch Connor]

Been told last night Gus is meeting with James seggyaro for a train and trial contract over the summer
Would most likely be second tier $80k-$110k only
And doesn’t take a spot from the fulltime roster

He had talks with us pre covid so there has definitely been interest from both parties. Expect him to line back up for Newtown if nothing eventuates though.

 

[finchie]

He had talks with us pre covid so there has definitely been interest from both parties. Expect him to line back up for Newtown if nothing eventuates though.

Worth a shot for a tier two contract
If he impresses in the preseason and with the new additions then why not