2022 Hooker

cookieman909 said:
We need to stop buying other clubs rejects that don’t make the top 17.
Click to expand...

Make no mistake Kenny is rated by the Panthers. They chose him over Egan/Katoa. Just so happens we got Api later who's one of the best in the comp otherwise Kenny would be the 9 permenantly.
 
Oldpanther said:
Make no mistake Kenny is rated by the Panthers. They chose him over Egan/Katoa. Just so happens we got Api later who's one of the best in the comp otherwise Kenny would be the 9 permenantly.
Click to expand...

In fairness it's not asking much to be more highly regarded than Egan and Katoa. Egan is the dumbest, most selfish hooker in the comp and Katoa can't pass to save his life.

Kenny has been good this season, but Starling or Simpkin offer way more upside.
 
Last edited:
CaptainJackson said:
No one is saying he's the answer. There are only a minimal amount of top class hookers, what do we do if we can't get them? Do we rely on JMK and Katoa for another 3 years? Or would we at least have someone like Kenny as a backup option if we can't get a top class hooker?
Click to expand...
There’s several good #9s in the UK, QLD cup, NSW cup and I’ll add Deitz is better than Kenny. Deitz is our back up option.
 
Above Kenny, I have Havili (Raiders) Joey Lussick (Eels), Billy Walters (Tigers) Sam Powell (Wigan), Kruise Leeming (Leeds), Matt Parcell (Hull). I’m still confident we can land B Smith.
 
Elite, proven, genuine running 9 would be great.!!
 
D.O.W. said:
Above Kenny, I have Havili (Raiders) Joey Lussick (Eels), Billy Walters (Tigers) Sam Powell (Wigan), Kruise Leeming (Leeds), Matt Parcell (Hull). I’m still confident we can land B Smith.
Click to expand...

I reckon we have him already and are chasing the hell out of J.Bromwich.
 
_G-Dog_ said:
Where Billy Ngwini when u need him..
Click to expand...

I thought I would look him up to see what he is doing these days.

"For the 2017/2018 season he joined Irish Junior rugby team Wicklow Town RFC, playing in Leinster Division 1A, deploying his step alongside such greats as Dean H Leonard and Tommy O Donovan. Playing at scrum half and winger Billy scored many tries and received many many yellow cards."

It's from Wikipedia so you never know the veracity of it.
 
Why arent we in discussions with a hooker to trade with from another club?
Must have numb hands at belmore from sitting on them all the time.
 
cookieman909 said:
We need to stop buying other clubs rejects that don’t make the top 17.
Click to expand...

Yep agree mate but in some instances the club is wrong.

Manly got rid of Korosau
Papenhausen was shipped around by the storm in 2019
 
I know this Clarkey is a muppet, but shouldn't we be making moves like this. Screenshot_20210408_213124.jpg
 
The Faz said:
I know this Clarkey is a muppet, but shouldn't we be making moves like this. View attachment 22933
Click to expand...
Yes/no. We need Brandon Smith before Daryl Clark. If we miss out on both it could be devastating tho (relying on a contracted player to pop up).
 
Simpkins at tigers is leading the comp is tries, tackles. I think he is also in the top 5 for line break. Broncos Jnr so you’d think he won’t be a long term option. But worth contacting his agent and letting him know if he comes over the 9 is his.

Apart from that maybe a handful of players that could be decent. But none really elite. Funny to see Mahoney is at the top of the dally m tally so far. Kids been going great to start the season.

Best bet we have is clear the decks and have a 1.1 million dollar contract ready for grant come next contract. Offer him 3 years 3.3 million dollars. He will be worth every cent (look what he did in half a game of origin last year).
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top