14 players on the field (Merged)

[Hansta]

Hay Im from Penrith

 

[Wahesh]

Im about to galavanise my foot up ur ass

http://www.i-am-bored.com/bored_link.cfm?link_id=21482

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L45mM0boiy4

 

[Toey .H.C.]

dogs are the victims here

the nrl always do everything in their power to bring us down

im sick of this

 

[BTK]

http://www.i-am-bored.com/bored_link.cfm?link_id=21482

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L45mM0boiy4

Thats where i got it from lol

 

[Wahesh]

Thats where i got it from lol

lol made me crack up laughing at first. then seeing Hany's directly underneath your post made me literally lol even though it was related to a different post lol.

 

[byebyeUTAI]

Is my eyes playing tricks on me or is the player they've tagged #13 doesn't look to be wearing Dogs colors? :whacky:

if you count off either sid eof the ruck penriff are manned up on us... even with some lazy panthers player marked up on ryan who is in backplay...

this effectively gives us an extra player in the ruck and how we created and overlap... so without even touching the ball it could be argued ryan did have an effect on the game

going to be hard to argue any different... we should try to get the penalty downgraded but we have zero chance imo...

 

[BulldogStar]

if you count off either sid eof the ruck penriff are manned up on us... even with some lazy panthers player marked up on ryan who is in backplay...

this effectively gives us an extra player in the ruck and how we created and overlap... so without even touching the ball it could be argued ryan did have an effect on the game

going to be hard to argue any different... we should try to get the penalty downgraded but we have zero chance imo...

Is Andrew Ryan even on the field in this image, or standing just off it. Sorry my eyes arent that good

 

[Rodzilla]

Is Andrew Ryan even on the field in this image, or standing just off it. Sorry my eyes arent that good

even if he standing off it, he comes on later

he can be seen celebrating the try

 

[BulldogStar]

even if he standing off it, he comes on later

he can be seen celebrating the try

oh i know he definitly came back on, Ive watched the footage a number of times and i can see him.

MY question is about the 'proof' picture

 

[Rodzilla]

oh i know he definitly came back on, Ive watched the footage a number of times and i can see him.

MY question is about the 'proof' picture

it doesnt matter really, because i dont think it is the defining piece of evidence that the nrl will be looking at

 

[BulldogStar]

it doesnt matter really, because i dont think it is the defining piece of evidence that the nrl will be looking at

No it wont matter in the grand scheme of things haha, but if the telegraph or wherever this image has been lifted from is listing this as proof, i cant actually see the proof in the image

 

[byebyeUTAI]

in the photo ryan is standing inside whoever is tagged at #13 (haz I assume).. so ryan has to be on the field

 

[MP4 - Eedz]

The image means nothing cause we ackowledge the 14th man

Our drama is the severity of the punishment. Once Ennis was injuried it was 13 on 13 all the way to the try, fair game, illegal yes thats why we need a punish

But 2 competition points is unfair IMHO

 

[Captain Kickass]

Since the merging of all threads, I just wanted to re-iterate this one point !

"On the grounds of consistancy, here presents an oppportunity for the NRL, to finally show some !

Anything greater than a fine for this "mistake" is a ludicrous over-reaction by an organisation already under question for their choice of punishments on several issues, recently !"

 

[chadiwrx]

in the photo ryan is standing inside whoever is tagged at #13 (haz I assume).. so ryan has to be on the field

Assuming #13 is Haz the person thats inside #13 is Idris (#12) not Ryan

 

[Dognacious]

Since the merging of all threads, I just wanted to re-iterate this one point !

"On the grounds of consistancy, here presents an oppportunity for the NRL, to finally show some !

Anything greater than a fine for this "mistake" is a ludicrous over-reaction by an organisation already under question for their choice of punishments on several issues, recently !"

Yes. A fine is exactly what we deserve, as the extra player (Ryan) takes no part in the play and doesnt change the result. Anything else could come across as victimising us.

 

[Moronic Musings]

i reckon the rule should be just players involvedshould be charged if they were a 14th man !

 

[byebyeUTAI]

Assuming #13 is Haz the person thats inside #13 is Idris (#12) not Ryan

#13 is haz, #12 is idris, #14 is ryan...

ryan is standing further infield than haz...

bulldogstar was pointing out if ryan was on the field... all i said was he was standing further infield than haz so he must be

 

[Rodzilla]

lol we are on the PTI australia rundown on espn

 

[kimlo]

wow 96 pages? lol
I cbf reading throught that.