The jury is always and will be out regarding a proven coach. Best example is the mongrel coaching our team.
So really its hard to predict who will succeed. But ultimately I'd like to have someone on board that can bring back our tough bulldog brand.
I've always wanted Dymock but he's not interested so I'd go with Pay for his understanding of the club and his time under experienced coach's, + he's had good wraps on him too btw.
Holbrook another 1, i believe he's come to a point in his career were deserves a shot and will get it imo.