I disagree with pretty much everything you have stated.
A huge percentage of United's fan base world wide must be odd as well.
I can't speak for the United fan base but ...
I'd agree about Shaw as his form last year leading into this year has put him in that bracket. Wouldn't say he's "one of the best" just yet, but he's definitely up there and just needs to show it consistently on the field.
The rest?
I think what he's saying is that players like Martial & Rashford have had top seasons at United throughout their time there and that can't be argued. I'd counter that though by saying have they been consistently good? I mean, this is the great demonstration of top coaching when a player goes from being a little hot in the pan to a consistent top level. Both for me have been a let down, but I'm not a United fan.
McTominay. Interesting one as many on here seem to rate, and fair enough. Fred is pretty much rubbish, but I haven't seen much better from McTominay this year? And definitely not a big enough improvement to class him as a success. Would he get into the first 11 of top 4 opposition teams?
Greenwood is fucking great. HATE that he's playing with you. What I will say is that defensively he's still got some learning, especially with his tracking back though maybe that's the plan of Ole? I don't know?
I think people are making this 'Ole debate' a little bit too one side or the other. For me, he's done well to consolidate United and put you in a place where you can take those next steps. My argument is that he's not the person to take you on those next steps, that's all. He's done alright all things considered, but not enough.