Round 19 - Dogs vs Eels - NRL / NSWC / NYC Team List & Discussion Thread

[CrittaMagic69]

Super Mod to the rescue!

 

[Raysie]

We all know Mbye is the future, but he isn't our man for 2015.

If we're even a chance of winning the Premiership this year we need experience to get us there. If Hodkinson and Reynolds is what Hasler thinks is our best chance of success for 2015, then I'm on-board.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

We all know Mbye is the future, but he isn't our man for 2015.

If we're even a chance of winning the Premiership this year we need experience to get us there. If Hodkinson and Reynolds is what Hasler thinks is our best chance of success for 2015, then I'm on-board.

So our leading try assister is not good enough?

 

[Raysie]

So our leading try assister is not good enough?

He's only our leading try assister because he's played the most games and time.

 

[Izzy Forreal]

Surely des didn't drop mbye cause of the Broncos game Reynolds is usually of the bench

I can't believe he has. In attack the Broncos game was an error ridden schmozzle, no one looked good. The big positive that came out of it was our defence; the Broncos only managed a three tries to two win although they had 60% possession and a few handy penalties on the back of our errors.

 

[Doggies2015]

So our leading try assister is not good enough?

He and josh both have 6 with Trent on 5 try assists

 

[CrittaMagic69]

He's only our leading try assister because he's played the most games and time.

Not really. He spent a 1/3rd of his time out at centre also. He has been put best half all year, our left edge is the second strongest in the comp, and he has ben a major part of it. To drop him for either of those 2 is pathetic.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

He and josh both have 6 with Trent on 5 try assists

Moses is on 7 mate, Trent 6 and Reynolds 5.

 

[alic]

Dessie at his best, got the whole kennel firing over the team list,just wait to game day,Moses will start no doubt about it

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Not really. He spent a 1/3rd of his time out at centre also. He has been put best half all year, our left edge is the second strongest in the comp, and he has ben a major part of it. To drop him for either of those 2 is pathetic.

Also to add, Hodko is at .5 TA per game. Moses .47 and Reynolds .42. If you wanna know it broken down.

 

[Doggies2015]

Moses is on 7 mate, Trent 6 and Reynolds 5.

Not where I get my info from

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Not where I get my info from

You need a better stats site then lol

 

[Doggies2015]

Where's your info from

 

[Boxer]

Loko is dead average. Everyone that hypes him up hasnt seen him play

A lot of people are talking him up I personally have never seen him play and would love to see what the hype is about

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Where's your info from

nrlstats.com and totalfootystats.com.au

 

[Heckler]

What is it with people on this forum suggesting to throw players out of position when we have ample of talent in NSW Cup to fill in or replace players out of form in first grade

I'm not suggesting, I'm as dumbfounded as you are. Just trying to make out Des' thoughts are...that all pup.

 

[Sandra's Bollocks]

so we've gone from 4 forwards, to 3 forwards, to now 2 forwards on the bench. des has truly lost the plot hahahaha.

 

[Abzsalam99]

so we've gone from 4 forwards, to 3 forwards, to now 2 forwards on the bench. des has truly lost the plot hahahaha.

2???? I'm sure it's 3

 

[finchie]

The parrascum left attacking edge is the most potent in the comp and they will have a field day against perret, lafai and Reynolds if things haven't improved from last week.

 

[Mr Invisible]

Not sure what Hasler's thinking bringing Hodko back in.

Might be losing games but at least we are scoring points with Mbye & Reynolds combination.