Regarding Josh Addo Carr

Should Josh Ado Carr be sacked?

  • Yes

    Votes: 151 48.7%

  • No

    Votes: 159 51.3%
  • Total voters
    310
Status
Not open for further replies.
ASSASSIN said:
Don't want him or need him. He isn't a modern day winger. When he is actually on the field he fucks up more tries than he scores.
Click to expand...

Disagree mate. He is a genuine threat every time the ball gets near him. And we could get him for half price now with any luck.
 
rexest said:
Yeah lets punt an established gun winger and become like parra 2 years of below avg wingers costing them games on more then 1 occasion, Destroy our depth strengthen a rival club.
Click to expand...
Fkn lol yeah we are parra now....
 
Micko said:
Disagree mate. He is a genuine threat every time the ball gets near him. And we could get him for half price now with any luck.
Click to expand...
So you think the nrLOL will let us re-sign him at nearly half his price?
 
I want to ask everyone something ,some might be naive ,but I know Josh has made a big mistake and his manager has ill advised him also to double down why who knows,so tell me .
Is Josh the only player who has ever taken something at our club? Speaking to someone in the know reckons 50 percent of players do it .
If you make a mistake, just own it
 
rexest said:
Yeah lets punt an established gun winger and become like parra 2 years of below avg wingers costing them games on more then 1 occasion, Destroy our depth strengthen a rival club.
Click to expand...
Cry
 
ASSASSIN said:
So you think the nrLOL will let us re-sign him at nearly half his price?
Click to expand...

Yes I do. Especially after ‘bringing the cane into disrepute’

Sacking him now dies nothing for us. Waiting and thinking can really help our premiership chances in the future.

I understand you feel that we lost Skelton because of him. But that’s most likely not the case. Skelton probably didn’t cut it in our defensive system.
 
This is like a hole to the heart on finals eve, 8 years in the making. Let's be serious. If this were a panthers, roosters, or storm player, we'd be saying they're gone. They will just lose that edge, that focus. I feel we are fucked, shit way to go out after a cracking season.

Sent from my SM-S921B using Tapatalk
 
Micko said:
Yes I do. Especially after ‘bringing the cane into disrepute’

Sacking him now dies nothing for us. Waiting and thinking can really help our premiership chances in the future.

I understand you feel that we lost Skelton because of him. But that’s most likely not the case. Skelton probably didn’t cut it in our defensive system.
Click to expand...
Lol bringing in Tigpie...

He isn't a modern day winger, he isn't needed. Don't really care how good he was a year or two ago. Fox's defence is as bad as Skeltons.
 
Dogmonster said:
To many high profile players we get rid of punish us by scoring tries and beating our arse, i think he would be ashamed and wanting to make the club happy if he is given the chance. But If it means we get RCG and a decent winger then yeah.
Still sad for everyone especially young boys when they lose a favourite like JAC.
Click to expand...

Kids are devastated only 7 years old an apparently all anyone was talking about at school


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top