Regarding Josh Addo Carr

Should Josh Ado Carr be sacked?

  • Yes

    Votes: 151 48.7%

  • No

    Votes: 159 51.3%
  • Total voters
    310
Status
Not open for further replies.
InGusWeTrust said:
Funny how most people are all aboard the Xerri train but most are now right off the Foxx train lol. Just interesting psychology when one did steroids and the other has been caught with coke in his system. Yes, Xerri did his time, but look at all other cases of players caught doing coke. Max 4 or 5 weeks.

Actually Trindall only served 5 weeks it seems and this was his incident…

“At 9.45am on Monday on his way to Cronulla training to attend a mandatory recovery session, Trindall was stopped by police and recorded a mid-range alcohol reading of 0.125 as well as a positive test for an illicit substance.”

Didn’t know he blew mid range alcohol. That plus coke yet he only got suspended 5 weeks (actually may have been 7 or something as I think Sharks stood him down initially) is surprisingly lenient. Drink driving is much more serious imo. Being more than double the limit he’s just lucky no one was hurt.
Click to expand...
It’s not the drugs it’s the lying several times to Gus, Ciro and the fan base
 
Cook said:
I feel sorry for Fox. Very poor thing to do, yet i can see him staying on for final year. First offence isnt it?? Not biggest offence either
Click to expand...
Not his first offense of lying
 
Flanagun said:
He definitely increased his chances of getting caught.... but the dude has lost two very close people in his life to suicide... and may or may not have known how long it stays in the system. I think people on here are being pretty harsh with him, all things considered.
Click to expand...
I don't get this take though tbh.

Lots of people have lost loved ones for different reasons, football players no doubtedly included in that list.

Why aren't they all wracking up lines?

Of course, we all have our own ways of dealing with mental health challenges but at some point we need to draw the line.

He's a high profile player making an incredible amount of money with an absolute mountain of support around him. Better support than I'd say 95% of people btw.

The expectations are always going to be higher for a player in his position, especially when he clearly lied about it and allowed his boss to take the brunt of the situation.
 
Cook said:
Yeah forgot about the dishonesty part. Where he lie before?? Was that the guns on latrell property during covid
Click to expand...
The koori knock-out bullshit.
 
Shreksno1 said:
Think you’re taking the club first motto a little to literally there my bro, we look after our own take your emotions out of it
Click to expand...
I've been honest from the start bro, he is broken and aging, waste of 550k. This is our chance to get rid of him.
 
I think Gus knew that it would come back positive but hoped it didn’t
 
l
KiwiDog7 said:
It’s not the drugs it’s the lying several times to Gus, Ciro and the fan base
Click to expand...

I agree that part isn’t great but as I said before there has to be more to it because he vehemently denied it according to Gus. For all we know he told them but they said what they said to media to try and save face for JAC. I just think there’s some details that haven’t been exposed yet.
 
Micko said:
But what if this gives us a chance to get him for 300k
Click to expand...
Don't want him or need him. He isn't a modern day winger. When he is actually on the field he fucks up more tries than he scores.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top