Napa Consolidated Discussion Thread

[CrittaMagic69]

People need to stop talking about stats.. would you take mason or tolman?? Cases closed

Stop talking stats because it totally pokes holes in your made up theories? Ha. And just to top off you comment, you then stupidly claim Tolmans stats would look better than Masons? Bahahaha.

 

[El_Magic]

Fuck klem the pussy ****. Not worth anywhere near that amount. **** spends more time on his back than a hooker. Never bends the line, slows down and turns before the line every time.

 

[Turvey Chip and Chase]

Klemmer did his ACL in 2013 and missed most of the season so that’s why there’s that big of a difference.

... hope that doesn’t happen again

 

[GA45]

Better value signing for a prop. Welcome aboard Dylan

 

[Mackdoggies]

Funny how everyone has whinged for the last month saying we better sign someone decent to replace klemmer. We sign literally the best prop that was available and in our budget, everybody still whinges. Can’t wait to see Napa smash Klemmer and “earn the respect of the playing group”. A player that truly wants to impress, that’s the attitude we are trying to build here!

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Funny how everyone has whinged for the last month saying we better sign someone decent to replace klemmer. We sign literally the best prop that was available and in our budget, everybody still whinges. Can’t wait to see Napa smash Klemmer and “earn the respect of the playing group”. A player that truly wants to impress, that’s the attitude we are trying to build here!

I didn't want a prop, and that's like 50% of my argument against this signing.

 

[Mackdoggies]

I didn't want a prop, and that's like 50% of my argument against this signing.

Signing Napa for less than Klemmer gives us the money to spend on a back. We still have around 400-500k left in the budget now, that buys a decent centre if we can find one.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Signing Napa for less than Klemmer gives us the money to spend on a back. We still have around 400-500k left in the budget now, that buys a decent centre if we can find one.

And not signing Napa gives us even more money and essentially puts us in a position to go after any player that comes on the market. And 400-500k? You're assuming Napa was signed on nothing more than 400k...

 

[Spoonman84]

... hope that doesn’t happen again

To be fair I don’t think he’s been injured since but he does play a very physical style and sooner or later that has to take its toll on the body.

 

[CaptainJackson]

If Napa's defence is so impactful then why does he not feature here? I thought he was incredibly dominant in defence?


View attachment 8287

And what about klem bro?

Klem was usually 2nd or 3rd man into the tackle and would lay about.

Once in a while (not a game) he'd try to put on a big hit and miss

 

[CrittaMagic69]

And what about klem bro?

Klem was usually 2nd or 3rd man into the tackle and would lay about.

Once in a while (not a game) he'd try to put on a big hit and miss

And? Klemmer is irrelevant. I'm not arguing who's better or not, i'm simply dismissing the myth that Napa is some how an elite defender and extremely dominant. This is the same Kennel that came up with the myth of Tolman being an elite defender...same people at it again.

 

[bcmf]

... we couldn’t afford to pay 800k to klem?

 

[Bad Billy]

Meh, don’t know what to think about this.
If it happened overnight I’d be filthy, but we’ve had a month of bullshit about klemmer to get used to this, so I’m not too cut.
Honestly you can’t replace klemmer with anyone, but this guy will be close, and if he comes at a cheaper price, all the better.

 

[Howard Moon]

Except this isn't the 80s. The club targeted him because they have no ambition.

yeah you're right.. we should have signed somebody who isn't a rep player and recent premiership winner.. that would show real ambition

 

[KiwiDog7]

Round 9, 2019 [emoji897]

 

[Bad Billy]

Round 9, 2019 [emoji897]

Here or there ?

 

[KiwiDog7]

Here or there ?

It’s that magic round at Suncorp I think

Be good to see Napa go up against Chloe’s husband

 

[Blue&whiteAxe]

If Napa's defence is so impactful then why does he not feature here? I thought he was incredibly dominant in defence?


View attachment 8287

Stop being a sook mate and let people have an opinion for fuck sake. Get off here for a little bit and go watch some TV.

And? Klemmer is irrelevant. I'm not arguing who's better or not, i'm simply dismissing the myth that Napa is some how an elite defender and extremely dominant. This is the same Kennel that came up with the myth of Tolman being an elite defender...same people at it again.

tolman is an elite defender, as is Jackson.

 

[Bad Billy]

tolman is an elite defender, as is Jackson.

I just spewed in my mouth.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Stop being a sook mate and let people have an opinion for fuck sake. Get off here for a little bit and go watch some TV.

tolman is an elite defender, as is Jackson.

Point proven.