Mixed reviews are quite common especially on Rotten Tomatoes. For example..
Prey. 2nd best Predator and well loved by all. Amazing movie. Gets a semi-average user review score
View attachment 58693
Day Shift. Dead average movie that cost way too much to make. Audience liked it much more than critics
View attachment 58694
Elvis. Haven't seen it yet but every person I talk to absolutely loves it. Critics are well lower on it
View attachment 58696
The Gray Man. Possibly the most dead average movie ever made. No reason at all to make this movie and I have no idea how anyone can like it. And look at the audience score
View attachment 58697
People just need to understand that everyone is different, and professional critics will always analyse stuff differently to the general public.
I haven't watched Rings of Power yet, but I'm going in expecting an average TV show.