Mate, you are soo wrong with this one. The only thing, yes the ONLY thing that Montoya does is catch a high ball. His positional play in attack and defence is terrible, he hasn't beaten the opposition since the day he came into grade 18 months ago and when he eventually tries to tackle someone he has a worse than 50:50 chance of success. He scores no tries, saves no tries and the opposition tip sheet just says "there is someone posted out on the dogs right side but careful you might mistake him for a corner post". That would be it. The kid needs a long stint in the seconds just to see if he can play, because he is showing nothing with us.
As for Halligan, well I'm hardly a young supporter. I go back to the Johns era, but he was about as ordinary a winger as ever played the game. His only skill was kicking and no-one can take that away from him but he was still ordinary as a winger. Sadly, Montoya doesn't even kick does he......