Mackdoggies
Kennel Established
- Joined
- Oct 5, 2018
- Messages
- 604
- Reaction score
- 1,088
Lewis is nowhere near the build of Sutton or matterson. He would get killed at lock.
The problem would be getting extra hit ups and metres from elsewhere. 20 years ago Lewis would be the perfect lock and I’m not sure if you could get away with playing him at lock in todays game.Why wouldn’t Lewis work at lock currently ? All he does is tackle and tackles well he’s much better then Elliot at it. With no stars in our lineup maybe we need to think outside the box moving forward to get results.
I just don’t see the harm in trying it. If we had quality at Lock you wouldn’t think about it. Lewis needs to work on his attacking game and I believe Cogger needs to take the lead role with this lineup. Cogger has shown some nice things but Lewis seems to have taken the lead role when attacking atm. And it’s not prettyThe problem would be getting extra hit ups and metres from elsewhere. 20 years ago Lewis would be the perfect lock and I’m not sure if you could get away with playing him at lock in todays game.
Jackson is better lock.I just don’t see the harm in trying it. If we had quality at Lock you wouldn’t think about it. Lewis needs to work on his attacking game and I believe Cogger needs to take the lead role with this lineup. Cogger has shown some nice things but Lewis seems to have taken the lead role when attacking atm. And it’s not pretty
I’d rather Jacko personally for this year and I’d keep Lewis in the halves and see if he can make the adjustments in his game to cope with not having as much space and time as he did last year. If he still looks like he is struggling get him in the gym all off season then see how he can go in the back row.I just don’t see the harm in trying it. If we had quality at Lock you wouldn’t think about it. Lewis needs to work on his attacking game and I believe Cogger needs to take the lead role with this lineup. Cogger has shown some nice things but Lewis seems to have taken the lead role when attacking atm. And it’s not pretty
For sure. Jackson at lock makes sense. But if it’s going to be Elliot then get Lewis bulking up.I’d rather Jacko personally for this year and I’d keep Lewis in the halves and see if he can make the adjustments in his game to cope with not having as much space and time as he did last year. If he still looks like he is struggling get him in the gym all off season then see how he can go in the back row.
Totally agree he will end up being a gun half ive said on here a number of times he will make mistakes hes young we have to be patient,some on here are delusional they expect jt straight awayHis future os where he is right now and learning to do it better he is still learning his trade. Shit talk from ppl saying he needs to go to hooker or he isn't "creative" enough is pathetic considering the team as a whole are young and learning. It would be nothing short of stupidity to move players out of their postion hoping that the team is going to do better in our current situation
You need to tell pay thatThose aimless kicks on the 4th did my fkn head in
Kids got heart
Just wish he had brains too
Lewis, Cogger and Meaney need to dig into the line. None of this slow shifting passes. Too predictable. It’ll come with time though.Only trouble is lately both lewis and cogger are playing well before the line. Lewis is just pumping early ball wide and cogger has just been bringing players back on a inside line. It gives opposition defenders plenty of time to readjust. Both have gone away from digging into the line.
Meaney is not pushing up with our forwards instead just waiting out the back for a block play on 4 which they are slow to execute playing well back before the line. Absolutely nothing in attack.
There must be two things going on here. A lack of talent and skill, which we cant change until we go shopping, and coaching.
Look at the modern day locks with the exception of Victor Radley, they are all like another prop these days so Lewis would have no hope in the middleLock
Maybe he is not a natural but he does have the attributes to be a decent half, he was awesome towards the end of last season and has been playing in a bad roster since he made his debut.Has some great attributes but...
Not a running threat so never going to be a class centre.
Not a natural ball playing half or organiser and i cant see that changing.
His defensive ability suggests he is capable of having a decent career but i think needs to put on 10kg and become an edge player or ball playing lock or forget about NRL.
Brandon Smith - 180cm, 94kgLook at the modern day locks with the exception of Victor Radley, they are all like another prop these days so Lewis would have no hope in the middle