Opinion Biggest disapointment

[Berries]

Main signing tier list from 2010-
After factoring in salary, performance, longevity. King and RFM have potential to move up a tier but at this point you can't put them any higher

A tier - Guns:
Graham
B tier - Good signing:
Tolman, Pritchard, Perrett, Rona, JAC
C tier - Satisfactory/Pass:
CHN, Inu, M. King, Vaughan, Hodkinson, Burton
D tier - Bad signings:
RFM, JMK, B. Moz,
F Tier - flat out fails:
Allan, Thompson, Cotric, Hopoate, DWZ, Stimson, Waddell, Hetherington, Dufty,
P Tier - for the most putrid of signings:
Napa, T-Rex, Foran, Lichaa, Woods, Flanagan, TPJ

Forgot about 500k DWZ for three errors a game and 5 missed tackles

 

[ricko_29]

Cotric never got the ball, all he could do was try and run it out of his own half. People voting for him are on crack

Tony Williams on the other hand...
80minutes
5 runs
25 metres

Will never be beaten

What the fuck was Des smoking playing him 80 minutes, AND sticking with it for as long as he did.

TPJ has got to be up there for his efforts this year

and what a sad story big papa was, how desperate were we to sign someone going with him for 600k far out.

 

[Dogtime]

TPJ wins hands down. His fitness is awful. Can't contribute for even reasonable minutes. My only hope is that he sees how hard Kikau works at his fitness in the off season and decides to give it a red hot go.
If Ciraldo can't get him fit and engaged in the teams goals then Gould must shop him or he will drag us down. We cannot accept mediocrity.

 

[LordSidious66]

All the Barrett signings, chuck in Pangai too

Ado-Carr and Burton have been good. Even though they are Barrett signings.

 

[Mr Shhh]

Fred garbo briggs

Poor old Freddy was getting paid with coins.

 

[The Jerker]

Was hard to split Napa, Allen and Thompson.

-Napa because he was useless and lazy af.
-Allen because big contract and hardly even managed 1st grade.
-Thompson because heralded as top prop in the uk and possibly game. He’s been average.