2019 FG Squad...Thoughts...?

EB18 said:
Yeah im not sold on JMK as our 14 either. But who else would you put there?
Click to expand...

I wouldn’t mind 4 forwards on the bench. Ensures Tolman doesn’t play ridiculous minutes and our intensity is consistent over the 80. A genuine utility on the bench is only worth it if they can make a difference
 
EB18 said:
Other than goalkicking. In what is martin better then RFM who is an absolute beast? Those who think martin starts ahead of either CHN and RFM have rocks in the head.
Click to expand...

Halligan, El-Masri - not the best wingers in the world but the best goal kickers ever. Just saying, this has to come into consideration
 
Pappydog said:
Halligan, El-Masri - not the best wingers in the world but the best goal kickers ever. Just saying, this has to come into consideration
Click to expand...
Holland is a great goal kicker also. Admittedly not as good as martin. But we are not in a position to carry someone just for goal kicking. We need to pick the best players we have in each position then choose a goal kicker after that. As I said CHN and RFM in my opinion are way better than martin.
 
EB18 said:
Holland is a great goal kicker also. Admittedly not as good as martin. But we are not in a position to carry someone just for goal kicking. We need to pick the best players we have in each position then choose a goal kicker after that. As I said CHN and RFM in my opinion are way better than martin.
Click to expand...

I agree, they are, but you just have to find room for Martin, don’t you? Maybe centres? Do not underestimate the confidence the team gets knowing they can score tries anywhere on the field with a guarantee 6 points
 
EB18 said:
Holland is a great goal kicker also. Admittedly not as good as martin. But we are not in a position to carry someone just for goal kicking. We need to pick the best players we have in each position then choose a goal kicker after that. As I said CHN and RFM in my opinion are way better than martin.
Click to expand...
Well u will be carrying holland for goal kicking cause anyone that sees talent in that bloke needs to give me some of what there taking. Rfm did nothing to prove he is an 80 minute footballer unlike martin. Raymond will definitely have to pull his socks up if he wants long minutes.
 
Martin defends well, and can run a decent line and is a big body on the fringes. I would rotate CHN and RFM so we don't lose anything when one comes off and the other comes on.
 
Hulk76 said:
Martin defends well, and can run a decent line and is a big body on the fringes. I would rotate CHN and RFM so we don't lose anything when one comes off and the other comes on.
Click to expand...

Edge forwards should play 80.
 
EB18 said:
Holland is a great goal kicker also. Admittedly not as good as martin. But we are not in a position to carry someone just for goal kicking. We need to pick the best players we have in each position then choose a goal kicker after that. As I said CHN and RFM in my opinion are way better than martin.
Click to expand...
Martin will be in the 17. Mostly likely starting, because of his kicking. Holland will take over the duties when he’s subbed.

11. CHN
12. Martin
13. Jackson

14. Elliott
15. RFM
16. Sue
17. Fualalo (although I’d personally prefer Ogden - but I think Pay will choose Fualalo based upon his consistent selection this season)

We have a very good pack next season. Very capable bench and equally as capable depth in ISP.
 
We all seem to have forgotten that form should be and hopefully will be the main factor in team selection,
We are lacking quality in several positions and have bought players potentially to fill those positions, trials should determine who starts in first grade and who drops to reserves bearing in mind we might still add a quality player or two to the squad .
 
Blue&whiteAxe said:
Martin will be in the 17. Mostly likely starting, because of his kicking. Holland will take over the duties when he’s subbed.

11. CHN
12. Martin
13. Jackson

14. Elliott
15. RFM
16. Sue
17. Fualalo (although I’d personally prefer Ogden - but I think Pay will choose Fualalo based upon his consistent selection this season)

We have a very good pack next season. Very capable bench and equally as capable depth in ISP.
Click to expand...

Id say ogden will have the bench spot over sue
 
Straight18 said:
Well u will be carrying holland for goal kicking cause anyone that sees talent in that bloke needs to give me some of what there taking. Rfm did nothing to prove he is an 80 minute footballer unlike martin. Raymond will definitely have to pull his socks up if he wants long minutes.
Click to expand...
I never said Holland is any good. I just said his a great goal kicker. Ive got Holland in the team because we have absolutely noone else to put in the centres. We have no depth in the centre position we have no choice but to put Holland there unless we buy someone. While the edge backrow position we have alot of depth.

Besides if you really think Martin starts ahead of CHN,RFM or Jackson then tell me why he played in the nsw cup finals while r.smith and lewis didnt?
 
EB18 said:
I never said Holland is any good. I just said his a great goal kicker. Ive got Holland in the team because we have absolutely noone else to put in the centres. We have no depth in the centre position we have no choice but to put Holland there unless we buy someone. While the edge backrow position we have alot of depth.

Besides if you really think Martin starts ahead of CHN,RFM or Jackson then tell me why he played in the nsw cup finals while r.smith and lewis didnt?
Click to expand...
I'll tell you why he played, he played because he's been the captain of the team for 2 years now and he deserves to get a win.
 
Blue&whiteAxe said:
1. Hopoate
2. Crichton
3.
4. Holland
5. Smith
6. Lewis
7. Foran
8. Tolman
9. Lichaa
10. Klemmer
11. CHN
12. Martin
13. Jackson
14. Sue
15. elliott
16. RFM
17. Fualalo

18. Ogden
19. C.Smith
20. Toomaga
21. Cogger
22. JMK
23. Montoya
24. Meaney
25. Nu Brown
26. Burr
27. Tualau
28. Okenbour
28. Olive
29. Cerutto
30. Cleeland

Does anyone know if Cerutto & Cleeland have re-signed yet?
Click to expand...
Nick Meaney will slot into fullback...Hopoate in the centres
 
In the paper today it says lichha seen running around not having an offseason maybe in for a big season
 
doggieaaron said:
In the paper today it says lichha seen running around not having an offseason maybe in for a big season
Click to expand...
FFS, he’s a professional athlete, I’d be more pissed if he’s not running around.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top