Really can’t get my head around your take. He was one of our best two forwards this year… and replacement options seem very thin on the ground.
Agree to disagree, I guess.
Just want to see competent players in the team...not simply tryers or error prone....we've been hindered for far too long with this type of player. We need better.
He had a reasonable year in this his contract year this year but he's had 3 years to show us his dependability and effectiveness and only had one good year showing these necessary traits.
I was calling for him to be signed before he went to Manly and posted his Penrith highlight reel in a new suggested signings thread but unfortunately he hasn't seemed to have lifted his output or consistency. Maybe he will achieve that with another club and coach.
Just my opinion and good that you have more faith.
If Gus re-signs him I will be happy for him.