News Sport Confidential: Bulldogs make a play to recruit Payne Haas

Blow a million on Hass and our 23 and 18 year old halves can run the show. The two biggest issues for the past ten years have been lack of a hooker and halfback. First good hooker since Ennis 1 problem resolved, yet it has the feeling all over it we’re not going to sign a half. Cant win the comp without a halfback but it’s fine go blow more millions on fowards and when they injured we can blame why we aren’t competing on injuries beautfiul.
 
I know I’ll be in the minority here but I don’t want anymore 800k and over forwards. Considering haas would cost in excess of 1 mill probably closer to 1.2 I would much prefer we got two metre eaters worth $600k each. Our recent history of keeping big name players on the park hasn’t been great and I’d hate to have 1.2 sitting on the sideline with zero depth around them
 
Taumololo was the best running round. Signed massive deal, now not the best running around. Haas is the best, in two years time another punk comes through and will be the best. I’m all for signing him but not on a long term deal. Two year deal, prove itself
 
Freakzilla said:
Because he wants other clubs to pay it lol. He would never give a prop that.
Click to expand...

I dunno didn’t he upgrade and pay rcg something like 800k for 5 years? Haas is light years ahead.
 
Cook said:
Taumololo was the best running round. Signed massive deal, now not the best running around. Haas is the best, in two years time another punk comes through and will be the best. I’m all for signing him but not on a long term deal. Two year deal, prove itself
Click to expand...

I dunno. Taumaolo provided amazing value for large amount of his deal in my opinion. He’s still a weapon. Just can’t punch 80 minutes now and injuries take its toll
 
Probably be sitting on the sideline him and TPJ by round 3 knowing our luck.
 
Bulldogs09 said:
I dunno didn’t he upgrade and pay rcg something like 800k for 5 years? Haas is light years ahead.
Click to expand...

How much better is irrelevant. There are a number of props I'd pay 800k a season to but none a million plus. No team has ever won a comp paying a prop over 800k a season.
 
Freakzilla said:
How much better is irrelevant. There are a number of props I'd pay 800k a season to but none a million plus. No team has ever won a comp paying a prop over 800k a season.
Click to expand...

First I’ll say no disrespect as your posts are usually pretty clean.

Though this one, I think that’s a pretty creative post.

1 no team has won a premiership with the current cap….

2 if you follow that logic when rcg was signed by Gus at panthers the cap was much smaller and 800k for 5 years for rcg is light years more insane $ and length than say 1.2 for haas in my books.
 
Bulldogs09 said:
First I’ll say no disrespect as your posts are usually pretty clean.

Though this one, I think that’s a pretty creative post.

1 no team has won a premiership with the current cap….

2 if you follow that logic when rcg was signed by Gus at panthers the cap was much smaller and 800k for 5 years for rcg is light years more insane $ and length than say 1.2 for haas in my books.
Click to expand...

In his entire career Haas has 0 finals wins. Spending over a million a season on a prop is a recipe for disaster.
 
Freakzilla said:
In his entire career Haas has 0 finals wins. Spending over a million a season on a prop is a recipe for disaster.
Click to expand...
This is my concern when people state elevating freak athletes above actual gods like Webcke, Lazarus etc.
The best of the best are measured largely by their impact in finals and origin
 
Freakzilla said:
In his entire career Haas has 0 finals wins. Spending over a million a season on a prop is a recipe for disaster.
Click to expand...

Think it’s shifting again based on salary caps etc. anyway agree to disagree.
 
Freakzilla said:
In his entire career Haas has 0 finals wins. Spending over a million a season on a prop is a recipe for disaster.
Click to expand...
How many props over 800k a season won the Dally M/went close. He's a freak and an outlier to the rule. He's worth 1m imo but we'd obviously have to pay more considering our situation and everything else considered.
 
bradyk said:
How many props over 800k a season won the Dally M/went close. He's a freak and an outlier to the rule.
Click to expand...

Luke Brooks nearly won the Dally M. Individual awards mean nothing. Winning finals games is what matters.
 
Freakzilla said:
Luke Brooks nearly won the Dally M. Individual awards mean nothing. Winning finals games is what matters.
Click to expand...
Haas obviously the best prop in the game and you could debate all time already. That's more important than the Dally M of course. You couldn't say the same for Brooks at the time he won it. Also Bronco currently top 4 and we'd still have enough $ to sign an experienced 7 as well if 1 was available (e.g. Hunt) - for those worried about Haas almost getting the wooden spoon years ago while being their best player.
 
Cook said:
Taumololo was the best running round. Signed massive deal, now not the best running around. Haas is the best, in two years time another punk comes through and will be the best. I’m all for signing him but not on a long term deal. Two year deal, prove itself
Click to expand...
Lolo was the best for a long time though
 
Prefer a top halfback or fullback for any Haas money..
 
Yeah sure, Hass and why not just sign Cleary, hunt and munster while we're at it
 
The_Chimpster said:
Yeah sure, Hass and why not just sign Cleary, hunt and munster while we're at it
Click to expand...
Haas coming off contract and we have an open cheque book and Hunt would have to agitate a release because of Griffin getting sacked/not wanting to rebuild at Dragon. Cleary and Munster locked up at top teams so silly comparison.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top