Rep Sides

[Tazer]

Campese was my other pick. It's basically out of those two.

NSW has next to no experience, Barrett has been there before and done it, they need all the experience they need as they will be fielding a lot of debutants in this series, another debutant in the number 6 position might be too much.

I have Barrett in my team for that reason, however I am not sure if he has come out of rep retirement and I am betting the selectors will go for Campese. Either way I wouldnt be dissapointed or surprised if Campese got the nod, I just wanted the backline to have a little more experience.

Selcting Barrett would be a mistake IMO. I haven't seen him do anything in attack this year which could be considered creative in any way shape or form. I don't think its a coincidence either that Saints had their best game of the year so far while he was out injured. In my book he's second only to Anasta as the most over rated player in the NRL.
For mine its Campese at 5/8 and Sutton off the bench, as he can play lock, 5/8, second row or even centre at a stretch.

 

[BaYry Ward]

If Ryan Hoffman or Steve Turner get picked I'm not watching.

Other than that, I will sit and watch NSW get belted again.

 

[PantherPower83]

If you are looking at form...how many of you have the top 20 in your teams so far?

Dally M rankings

7. Trent Waterhouse (PEN)

6. Sam Thaiday (BRI)

6. John Sutton (SOU)

5. Nathan Hindmarsh (PAR)

5. Adam Blair (MEL)

5. Steve Price (NZ)

5. Scott Dureau (NEW)

5. Andrew Ryan (BUL)

5. Nathan Friend (GCT)

5. Craig Fitzgibbon (SYD)

4. Terry Campese (CAN)

4. Greg Inglis (MEL)

4. Billy Slater (MEL)

4. Fuifui Moimoi (PAR)

4. Preston Campbell (GCT)

4. Luke Lewis (PEN)

3- Paul Gallen (CRO)

3- Kurt Gidley (NEW)

3 - Peter Wallace (BRI)

3 - Darren Lockyer(BRI)

 

[Hansta]

andrew ryan is in the top 10 yet people want him dropped

 

[kimlo]

Wallace should be on more than 3.... he has 2 blinding games, round 2 and 3 he was absolutely brilliant and by far best on field, but anyway, when journos pick the dally m, it doesn't give it much credibility, penrith player giving points in a penrith match like in round 2 shows how stupid these can be sometimes.

 

[Vagabond]

NSW selectors picking on form?

Pigs may fly.

 

[giant]

holdswoth should be in the mix

 

[Dogged11]

My 10c Worth

NSW

1.Stewart
2.Hayne
3.Cooper
4.Monaghan
5.Woolfman
6.Campese
7.Wallace
8.Mason
9.Farah
10.Kite
11.Gallen
12.Hoffman
13.Sutton

14.Gidley
15.Creagh
16.Lafranchi/Stewart
17.Cross

Mason is there simply because he can lift for these one off games and NSW really needs to muscle up against a tough QLD pack

QLD

1.Slater
2.Boyd
3.Inglis
4.Hodges
5.Folau
6.Lockyear
7.Thurston
8.Price
9.Smith
10.Cinoceva
11.Myles
12.Thaiday
13.Stagg

14.Prince
15.Hannant
16.Taylor
17.Parker

Qld always looks to start tough and myles has never had a bad origin game.
If form counts for anything,Stagg gets the nod over johnson.

Result Qld 3-0

 

[gibbo2]

If you are looking at form...how many of you have the top 20 in your teams so far?

Dally M rankings

7. Trent Waterhouse (PEN)

6. Sam Thaiday (BRI)

6. John Sutton (SOU)

5. Nathan Hindmarsh (PAR)

5. Adam Blair (MEL)

5. Steve Price (NZ)

5. Scott Dureau (NEW)

5. Andrew Ryan (BUL)

5. Nathan Friend (GCT)

5. Craig Fitzgibbon (SYD)

4. Terry Campese (CAN)

4. Greg Inglis (MEL)

4. Billy Slater (MEL)

4. Fuifui Moimoi (PAR)

4. Preston Campbell (GCT)

4. Luke Lewis (PEN)

3- Paul Gallen (CRO)

3- Kurt Gidley (NEW)

3 - Peter Wallace (BRI)

3 - Darren Lockyer(BRI)

are you suggesting that based opn form Scott Durea should be the NSW half back?

 

[PantherPower83]

are you suggesting that based opn form Scott Durea should be the NSW half back?

No

 

[bulldogs2010]

Nuu Zuuland

01. Sam Perrett
02. Taniela Tuiaki
03. Steve Matai
04. Krisnan Inu
05. Manu Vatuvei
06. Benji Marshall
07. Nathan Fien
08. Nathan Cayless
09. Issac Luke
10. Roy Asotasi
11. Simon Mannering
12. Frank Pritchard
13. Jeremy Smith

14. Sam Rapira
15. Adam Blair
16. David Fa'alogo
17. Setaimata Sa

Stacy Jones has retired from International football. Correct? If he hasn't, I'd definately have him as the 7. I'm sure he has though.

If your going by form, I'd have Roberts in the 6. He makes halfbreaks every single game. Marshall is so inconsistant. His dubbed a superstar for what he did in 05. He dead-set has about 5 decent games a season.

LOL Dogged 11. Mason has played 2 games this season and made less than 100 M in both and you put him as starting prop for orgin? amazing.

NSW lose the series every year because they never pick players based on form.

Someone tell me what did Brett White ever do to get into Origin? Be Bellamy
s cats at the storm.

Hoffman also. His crap. How he made it to Origin, i'll never know.

They should follow form. Looking forward to City V Country so we can see this "Origin trial".

The wing and centre spots have good competition this year for NSW.

Centres in contention: Josh Morris, Joel Monaghan, Michael Jennings, Matt Cooper. These guys are the only people I see as centres for NSW.

Wingers: Michael Gordon, John Williams, David Williams, Akuila Uate, Chris Lawrence, Jarryd Hayne even Bryson Goodwin is playing good footy.

It will be interesting to say the least. The only real depth NSW have is in the 2nd row. G

 

[Hansta]

If your going by form, I'd have Roberts in the 6. He makes halfbreaks every single game. Marshall is so inconsistant. His dubbed a superstar for what he did in 05. He dead-set has about 5 decent games a season.

By form Marshall is owning him lol. Please dont even put Marshall anywhere near roberts. Marshall owns that spot 100%

btw you cant put current form then say inconsistency in the same line. You can only pick 1

 

[kimlo]

Stacy Jones has retired from International football. Correct? If he hasn't, I'd definately have him as the 7. I'm sure he has though.

If your going by form, I'd have Roberts in the 6. He makes halfbreaks every single game. Marshall is so inconsistant. His dubbed a superstar for what he did in 05. He dead-set has about 5 decent games a season.

LOL Dogged 11. Mason has played 2 games this season and made less than 100 M in both and you put him as starting prop for orgin? amazing.

NSW lose the series every year because they never pick players based on form.

Someone tell me what did Brett White ever do to get into Origin? Be Bellamy
s cats at the storm.

Hoffman also. His crap. How he made it to Origin, i'll never know.

They should follow form. Looking forward to City V Country so we can see this "Origin trial".

The wing and centre spots have good competition this year for NSW.

Centres in contention: Josh Morris, Joel Monaghan, Michael Jennings, Matt Cooper. These guys are the only people I see as centres for NSW.

Wingers: Michael Gordon, John Williams, David Williams, Akuila Uate, Chris Lawrence, Jarryd Hayne even Bryson Goodwin is playing good footy.

It will be interesting to say the least. The only real depth NSW have is in the 2nd row. G

lol, I'd take marshall over roberts in any team, against any team any day of the week.

Don't kid yourself, when marshall is on fire he is one of the best 5/8's in the game.

Benji>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>Daylight>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>roberts.

They are both inconsistent, (but one has injuries as a genuine excuse one has no excuses) but when both on fire, marshall is a LOT better.

 

[FaceBreaker]

Stacy Jones has retired from International football. Correct? If he hasn't, I'd definately have him as the 7. I'm sure he has though.

If your going by form, I'd have Roberts in the 6. He makes halfbreaks every single game. Marshall is so inconsistant. His dubbed a superstar for what he did in 05. He dead-set has about 5 decent games a season.

LOL Dogged 11. Mason has played 2 games this season and made less than 100 M in both and you put him as starting prop for orgin? amazing.

NSW lose the series every year because they never pick players based on form.

Someone tell me what did Brett White ever do to get into Origin? Be Bellamy
s cats at the storm.

Hoffman also. His crap. How he made it to Origin, i'll never know.

They should follow form. Looking forward to City V Country so we can see this "Origin trial".

The wing and centre spots have good competition this year for NSW.

Centres in contention: Josh Morris, Joel Monaghan, Michael Jennings, Matt Cooper. These guys are the only people I see as centres for NSW.

Wingers: Michael Gordon, John Williams, David Williams, Akuila Uate, Chris Lawrence, Jarryd Hayne even Bryson Goodwin is playing good footy.

It will be interesting to say the least. The only real depth NSW have is in the 2nd row. G

LMAO @ Roberts over Marshall, only a true dogs fan can suggest this.

Roberts in the best form of his life would never take the spot of an out of form Marshall even.

 

[TAHU]

NSW Fullback options:
- Kurt Gidley
- Brett Stewert
- Luke Patten
- To some extent Ben Hornby

Patten is third in line and could get a shot this year due to injuries.

Five Eigth:
- Terry Campese
- Braith Anasta
- John Sutton
- Jarrod Mullen
- Trent Barret

Half Back:
- Peter Wallace
- Mitchell Pearce
- Brett Kimmorely
- Mullen again

I'd go with:
1. Stewart
6. Campese
7. Wallace
9. Farah
14. Gidley

Out side back qualities arent like Inglis Falou and Hodges

 

[PantherPower83]

I'd go with:
1. Stewart
6. Campese
7. Wallace
9. Farah
14. Gidley

That looks right

 

[MPS]

1) K. Gidley
2) J. Monaghan
3) L. Lewis
4) M. Cooper
5) C. Best
6) T. Campese
7) P. Wallace
8) B. Kite
9) R. Farah
10) L. Bailey
11) N. Hindmarsh
12) B. Creagh
13) F. Mateo

14) M. Weyman
15) T. Waterhouse
16) J. Sutton
17) B. Hornby

 

[pillow]

1) K. Gidley not good enough at fullback, better imact player
2) J. Monaghan ranga fail/overrated
3) L. Lewis lol
4) M. Cooper
5) C. Best lol
6) T. Campese
7) P. Wallace
8) B. Kite
9) R. Farah ennis has played far better this year
10) L. Bailey
11) N. Hindmarsh not the player he used to be
12) B. Creagh
13) F. Mateo maybe, hes not playing llike he did last year..

14) M. Weyman
15) T. Waterhouse
16) J. Sutton
17) B. Hornby

I agree with a couple of those positions, and lol at the others

 

[Howsie]

Anyone who thinks Michael Ennis will get in over Robbie Farah must be F#cking joking right, Farah ****'s all over Ennis.

 

[pillow]

I hate all the people that jizz over Farah. He's done nothing this year to impress me.