Rd 10 Dogs vs Dragons 3-2-1

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dognacious

Kennel Immortal
Staff member
Administrator
Premium Member
2 x NF Draft Champ
Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
25,010
Reaction score
12,964
3- Thompson
2- Meaney
1- Foran (would have been more if he played more than 1 half)
 
Foran= 3 (I don't care how long he played he was still the best player)
Meaney = 2 (one of the best games I have seen him play)
Thompson = 1 (they need to give him the ball with more space and some decoys would be nice)

Go Dogs
 
3. RFM
2. Meaney
1. Foran
 
3 Thompson
2 RFM
1 Meaney
 
3. Meaney
2. RFM
1. Thompson
 
1. Meaney
2. Foran
3. Thommo.
 
Am I the only one who saw Meaney run down a skinny blind and when going into touch threw the ball to a Dragon player.That was a huge fuck up as we were 12 in front and early tackle.Also the 2 non contested bombs that both led to tries..Fullbacks are expected to at least contest them.
 
1st full game back at fullback in a while, started with some nerves as expected, eased into the game as it went on and made a couple of mistakes as any nrl player on most occasions do.

All round solid game and a good fullback. Will excel at the back with more time.
 
1st full game back at fullback in a while, started with some nerves as expected, eased into the game as it went on and made a couple of mistakes as any nrl player on most occasions do.

All round solid game and a good fullback. Will excel at the back with more time.
Solid game ?? This forum crucifies players for missing a tackle in a game,dropping balls,bad passes etc and you think that was a solid game...Try was laid on for him and never had to beat a player.Has had opportunity at back before and is regarded as 3rd string fullback.

I know I have been critical of him but I just don’t see anything of use in him.Defensively weak if you watch his positioning as well.
 
Solid game ?? This forum crucifies players for missing a tackle in a game,dropping balls,bad passes etc and you think that was a solid game...Try was laid on for him and never had to beat a player.Has had opportunity at back before and is regarded as 3rd string fullback.

I know I have been critical of him but I just don’t see anything of use in him.Defensively weak if you watch his positioning as well.
I gotta say. I think he had a solid game. Is he our long term option. Likely not. But I am willing to give him until Hoppa is back to prove himself.

Hoppa > Meany.
But id choose Meany of DWZ purely because there is no other option i know of until Hoppa is back. DWZ is woeful at FB, massive errors and no ball playing ability.
 
Solid game ?? This forum crucifies players for missing a tackle in a game,dropping balls,bad passes etc and you think that was a solid game...Try was laid on for him and never had to beat a player.Has had opportunity at back before and is regarded as 3rd string fullback.

I know I have been critical of him but I just don’t see anything of use in him.Defensively weak if you watch his positioning as well.
Ok.
 
Votes

Nick Meaney 19
Luke Thompson 14
Kieran Foran 11
Raymond Faitala-Mariner 11
Lachlan Lewis 5
Aiden Tolman 3
Chris Crichton 1

Player of the year points

3- Meaney
2- Thompson
1- Foran
1- RFM
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top