Rd 10 Dogs vs Dragons 3-2-1

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dognacious

Dognacious

Kennel Immortal
Staff member
Administrator
Premium Member
2 x NF Draft Champ
Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
25,020
Reaction score
12,990
3- Thompson
2- Meaney
1- Foran (would have been more if he played more than 1 half)
 
Foran= 3 (I don't care how long he played he was still the best player)
Meaney = 2 (one of the best games I have seen him play)
Thompson = 1 (they need to give him the ball with more space and some decoys would be nice)

Go Dogs
 
3. RFM
2. Meaney
1. Foran
 
3 Thompson
2 RFM
1 Meaney
 
3. Meaney
2. RFM
1. Thompson
 
1. Meaney
2. Foran
3. Thommo.
 
Am I the only one who saw Meaney run down a skinny blind and when going into touch threw the ball to a Dragon player.That was a huge fuck up as we were 12 in front and early tackle.Also the 2 non contested bombs that both led to tries..Fullbacks are expected to at least contest them.
 
1st full game back at fullback in a while, started with some nerves as expected, eased into the game as it went on and made a couple of mistakes as any nrl player on most occasions do.

All round solid game and a good fullback. Will excel at the back with more time.
 
khan said:
1st full game back at fullback in a while, started with some nerves as expected, eased into the game as it went on and made a couple of mistakes as any nrl player on most occasions do.

All round solid game and a good fullback. Will excel at the back with more time.
Click to expand...
Solid game ?? This forum crucifies players for missing a tackle in a game,dropping balls,bad passes etc and you think that was a solid game...Try was laid on for him and never had to beat a player.Has had opportunity at back before and is regarded as 3rd string fullback.

I know I have been critical of him but I just don’t see anything of use in him.Defensively weak if you watch his positioning as well.
 
Big M said:
Solid game ?? This forum crucifies players for missing a tackle in a game,dropping balls,bad passes etc and you think that was a solid game...Try was laid on for him and never had to beat a player.Has had opportunity at back before and is regarded as 3rd string fullback.

I know I have been critical of him but I just don’t see anything of use in him.Defensively weak if you watch his positioning as well.
Click to expand...
I gotta say. I think he had a solid game. Is he our long term option. Likely not. But I am willing to give him until Hoppa is back to prove himself.

Hoppa > Meany.
But id choose Meany of DWZ purely because there is no other option i know of until Hoppa is back. DWZ is woeful at FB, massive errors and no ball playing ability.
 
Big M said:
Solid game ?? This forum crucifies players for missing a tackle in a game,dropping balls,bad passes etc and you think that was a solid game...Try was laid on for him and never had to beat a player.Has had opportunity at back before and is regarded as 3rd string fullback.

I know I have been critical of him but I just don’t see anything of use in him.Defensively weak if you watch his positioning as well.
Click to expand...
Ok.
 
Votes

Nick Meaney 19
Luke Thompson 14
Kieran Foran 11
Raymond Faitala-Mariner 11
Lachlan Lewis 5
Aiden Tolman 3
Chris Crichton 1

Player of the year points

3- Meaney
2- Thompson
1- Foran
1- RFM
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top