How about some data on players published weights and heights;
Hughes at 1.93/110 is actually heavier and almost as tall as Fa'asuamaleaui 1.97/107
RFM at 1.90/110 is almost exactly the same weight and height as Guler 1.91/112
Pele at 1.90/132 (lighter now but still over 120) is actually heavier and almost as tall as RCG 1.93/115
Patolo at 1.85/110 is actually heavier and almost as tall as Horsburgh 1.88/109
Kikau at 1.95/116 is actually heavier and almost as tall as NAS 2.00/115
TPJ at 1.90/117 is the same weight and almost as tall as Haas 1.94/117
The problem is the 6 Bulldogs players above have never all played at the same time this year.
History tells us it's not the size of the Bulldog in the fight, it's the amount of fight in the Bulldog (Exhibit A - Steve Folkes)
Always a Bulldog
No one said we don’t have any big body’s in our squad, we do, but I don’t get what you’re trying to say by comparing some of our young new to 1st grade blokes, to some of the best 1st grade and representative seasoned players in the league.
Tino Fa'asuamaleaui, Australian & Origin representative player, played 80 1st grade games …
Hughes has played 3 1st grade games he does show promise but should only be coming off the bench in short stints as he matures into a 1st grade prop.
RCG is 115kg he’s 29 he’s an Australian & Origin representative prop who’s played 191 games ….
Pele is 120kg he’s 22 and played 5 games yes he’s another one that shows promise, again, short stints off the bench while he matures into a 1st grade prop.
RFM plays his part but he’s no game changer, bench player at best, I don’t believe he should have been re-signed, lacks aggression.
We don’t know what Patolo can do we haven’t seen enough of him.
Kikau’s obviously quality.
TPJ 1/2 the player Haas is and plays 1/2 the minutes .. we can buy players and get 3 times the grunt and minutes he provides for his money.
Thompsons another one that’s never on the park, we can buy 2 players to provide twice the grunt and minutes for his money.
We lack experienced seasoned tough powerful run straight and hard line bending 1st grade props that scare the opposition.
Right now our biggest problem is our centres, they’re not tough enough or powerful enough to do the job we need them to do, not only do they have defensive issues but they also don’t break tackles at the rate most other centres do.
Alamoti is 19, .. 2023 10 games, 1 try, 16 tackle breaks, 80.02 tackle efficiency, 130 average run metres.
His last weeks Canberra centre counter part, Matthew Timoko, is 23, played 46 1st grade games, 2023 9 games, 3 try’s, 41 tackle breaks, 93.1 tackle efficiency .. 162 Av run metres ..
The difference there in tackle breaks & tackle efficiency and run metres tells me Alamoti needs 2 more years of cup footy to mature in toughness and power, work on his game, come back if he puts in the hard work when he’s 21, if he’s not willing to wait we move on.
Averillo is doing a good job at centre he’s lucky he has more 1st grade experience and most of all speed, but his good work is being undone with his 82.6 tackle efficiency, that needs to be well up over 90% … he’s only 22, with his speed and hands I believe he should be our 6 .. and train Oloapu to be a ball playing lock and come of the bench gradually as he matures into that role.
We need more power in our team, players that get us rolling down the field chewing up metres, 3 powerful props would be great & 2 tough powerful tackle busting centres with mongrel .. also I’m not sure Xerri suits that mold anymore either ..