Pay Extension

GA45

Kennel Addict
Joined
Apr 28, 2017
Messages
6,689
Reaction score
8,158
Black denotes who is the better. Red denotes a draw in said position

1. Hopoate / Thompson (Hoppa is easily better)
2. DWZ / Don (DWZ is clearly better, Don only has him covered in the air)
3. Holland / Kelly or Copley (all try their best but are liabilities in defence)
4. Averillo / Peachey (Peachey hasnt done nothing for years, Averillo has shown more attacking flair in his handful of games though, but will draw for experience sake)
5. Smith / Sami (both chill out on the wing doing nothing not looking for work, but both are talented when they apply themselves)
6. Foran / Taylor (ones a rep player who's won a premiership you do the math)
7. Wakeham / Fogarty (both unproven but i'm going with Wakeham as he's played reps)
8. Tolman / Fotiouaka (old warhorse has way more experience but im giving you a bone here as Mo is a good player)
9. Marshall-King / Rein (but both are shit, however Rein is the better attacker)
10. Napa / Jolliffe (no contest here Napa is shit but he's still better)
11. Jackson / Cartwright (no contest here, anti vax boy is scared of contact and cant tackle anything)
12. Mariner / Proctor (both pretty similar players currently as Proctor has regressed a lot since leaving Storm)
13. Elliot / Arrow (Arrow clearly better)

*left out CHN and Ryan James as were arguably the clubs best players and cancel each other out.

Looks like we have the ascendency in the spine and as a result should be the better side by a fair margin in attack... which reinforces the fact that our structures are pure shit...

* edit i forgot about Jarrod Wallace - just as mediocre as Napa but works harder so can give you that one if you wish.
Pretty spot on it’s BS when people say we have the worse roster in the NRL. People have just lowered their expectations because Pay has bought them down so far!!
 

AlzzBulldog

Kennel Legend
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
8,542
Reaction score
14,169
Pretty spot on it’s BS when people say we have the worse roster in the NRL. People have just lowered their expectations because Pay has bought them down so far!!
We’ve always had a decent mix of youth and experience, nothing special but just a very poorly coached side
 
Top