If you think so. I personally think that trip on barba was one of the dirtiest things. I have seen on a footy field. He could have ended his career. Yes yes I know it's barba etc etc but if that happened to a dogs player there would be calls for life bans on this forum.
Reynolds deserved what he copped, though his intent was to stop Barba from getting around him and not break his leg.
The worst I have seen this year was George Burgess arm bar on Matai. He did not try to stop the player or slow him down, he tried to pop his elbow and/or shoulder, and Matai did not return at all after he did fark his shoulder, he farked his shoulder while Matai was on the ground tackled
There is a difference between being a pest to get under the skin of an opponent to throw him off his game compared to trying to break an opponents bones while they have been tackled/submitted.
What do you think Taylor was trying to achieve with that head slam yesterday? He cops 1 week for that?
George Burgess cops 2 weeks for popping Matais shoulder and Te'o copped 4 weeks for the one on Thaiday even though Burgess's arm bar was 10 times worse?
A. Reynolds cops 1 week for the worst sphere tackle of the year while McClean copped 10+ games because a bloke ended up in a wheelchair, even though that was a pure accident. What would of A.Reynolds copped if Mbye ended up in a wheelchair? Finucane copped 1 week in the same game and how can you compare his tackle to A.Reynolds?
I understand J.Reynolds has brain farts and changes the momentum with his stupid antics but these blokes who go out to break bones are in a league of their own compared to J.Reynolds