Lock position debate

[ILiveForDib]

Personally I want Josh Jackson to be our lock. What about you?

(Admins fix debate if I did it wrong )

 

[Dogzof95]

The issue is we really don’t know what these players are capable of playing in a system that trusts their abilities (thank you Des)..... that’s why I chose RFM, he could be one of our X-factors!!!!

 

[2144superman]

None of the above mentioned should be in that lock position. Josh Jackson would be a waste there and we all saw what happened when Klemmer played there

 

[BELMORE]

None of the above mentioned should be in that lock position. Josh Jackson would be a waste there and we all saw what happened when Klemmer played there

Why would Josh Jackson be a waste there

 

[speedy2460]

I would have Tolman as lock. He is a tackling machine. (Never misses any).

 

[doggieaaron]

Jacko

 

[ILiveForDib]

None of the above mentioned should be in that lock position. Josh Jackson would be a waste there and we all saw what happened when Klemmer played there

Who then?

 

[EXPLORER]

Adam Elliot gets my vote

He reminds me finucane
A year or 2 under a decent coach who knows how to get the best out of him and we can have what the storm have in dale

 

[Sandra's Bollocks]

Tolman, as he can play a similar role to Stagg did. Plug the gaps in defence and let klem, woods and rfm run riot in attack. No more of this getting dominated bullshit.

 

[timetopisshasleroff]

Rhyse martin or rfm

 

[Bad Billy]

Tolman.
Not because I like him, but because it makes the most sense.
Klem and woodsy to start up front leaves tolman out of a starting spot, and even though that’d be fine by me, there’s no way we’re leaving a $700k forward on the bench.
Once tolmans gone, move jacko to lock.

 

[Dogna88]

8. Woods
9. Lichaa
10. Klemmer
11. Jackson
12. Elliot
13. Tolman

14. Eastwood
15. Fualalo
16. RFM
17. Mobile backrower.

 

[Bulldog_4_Life]

It should be Finucane. FUCK YOU DES.

 

[Bulldog_4_Life]

Between Jacko and RFM for me.

Jacko is our most effective tackler and can get fiery every now and again which is what you want in the middle but we don't haven't seen him given the chance to run any lines the last 5 years so I'd be inclined to start him on the edge for the first few games to see how he goes. In his debut year, he did run some pretty decent lines and definitely could in the U20's.

RFM can pop an offload no matter the situation and could be an X-Factor type player for us in the middle which will benefit Mbye the most from the back and if used right could be one of the best locks in the comp.

 

[ILiveForDib]

I want to experiment with both RFM and Jacko. @Bulldog_4_Life just pretty much posted what I was typing. Wow.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Tolman.
Not because I like him, but because it makes the most sense.
Klem and woodsy to start up front leaves tolman out of a starting spot, and even though that’d be fine by me, there’s no way we’re leaving a $700k forward on the bench.
Once tolmans gone, move jacko to lock.

Tolman isn't even on close to 700k lol.

 

[flamebouyant]

I think tolman should be our lock personally. He wont do us any good coming off the bench, and he will hold down that middle third so the other forwards can just worry about hitting rhe ball up hard and running good lines.
I actually dont have any issues with tolman like so many otgers do. Having him and graham as our starting props was just a fucking dumb ass move by our former so and so.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

A middle third of Woods, Klemmer and Tolman is slooooooooooowww. Need someone that can move in the 13 to balance the pack.

 

[ILiveForDib]

A middle third of Woods, Klemmer and Tolman is slooooooooooowww. Need someone that can move in the 13 to balance the pack.

RFM?

 

[no1bulldog]

i'd like to throw back to having a lock with some ball playing ability like when we used to have Dymock, Anasta or Jason Smith at lock..... I know many will say that's from back in the dinosaur days, but hey I reckon it could add some value...unfortunately I don't think we have a forward with any of those skills