Opinion josh Reynolds Discussion Thread

[GoTheDoggies]

Max 150k for Reynolds and bench utility only. That is the only deal I'd take to get him back.

 

[Papa Joe]

I said it before & I'll say it again-

I love what Josh done for us when he was with us & I think we got the best of Josh when he was here.
In saying that, taking him back now would totally be a step in the wrong direction - although it hurt when he left it was the right time to part company when we did.
Unfortunately for Josh he has been very unlucky with injuries since he has left and with his age he is too big a risk.

The equation is almost as simple as saying - take Josh back at the expense of Wakeham & Lewis for example, cause that's roughly what it might cost.

Young talent is the way forward - short term pain for long term gain.

 

[David holland]

This guy has to come as a Dog

 

[Squash the Berries!]

No thanks, would rather a real young hooker with some speed from dummy half who tackles with his hands not his feet and who won’t be another Foran, injury prone.

 

[Turvey Chip and Chase]

He doesn’t suit this board’s model of a prop and goal kicker....

Hooper is a Tigers fan, no shock he is “pushing” this “ideal situation” for the Bulldogs. Hooper is a “shandy” off going and getting fucked thanks.

Reynolds, loved him in his mid 20’s and his energy playing for us, but we need to be serious and rebuild, and that ship has sailed thanks.

No hate to reynolds, but not again.

 

[sgodllubsti]

reynolds and jmk and lichaa,
no and no and fuc% no

 

[KiwiDog7]

‍

 

[Vlasnik]

HELL NO!!!! Full stop.

 

[stinkypinky]

He should off taken a pay cut when he had the chance to stay

 

[bullanth]

He's on more than $700k per year + car. If we paid him half of that we'd be mad, we can get much better value for money.

Where?

 

[capt obvious]

Tigers must have someone else big lined up, but i cant see anyone taking even half of joshs freight at 400k in the nrl.

Id rather sezar if it came to that.

 

[doggieaaron]

He cant tackle certainly not at hooker

 

[Nasheed]

Nasheed here,
The problem is we have too many back up two bit. halves already.
Wakeham
Lewis
Stimson
Cogger
Brown
Foran
We also have Holland and Hoppa who could fill in at 5/8 if they needed too.

Yes I get that’s all of them may not be there next season, but only Nu Brown is likely to be chopped.

Foran also a guarantee when fit.

-Nasheed

 

[Nasheed]

I'd say no, but if we can get him for $300k and tigers pay remaining $500k for the next two years then I say why not?

Yeah but has to be that extreme.

 

[c-b-b]

Where?

On an up and coming hooker. Players like Braileys, Turpin, Liddle etc. They may not be top shelf 9's in some cases but will definitely play more than 9 games in 18 months.

I know some love to think of fairytale endings but it's time people see past that and consider what's best for the club, signing an aging injury prone utility at $350k would be a waste of cap space. I doubt he could even play 80 minutes at hooker.

 

[bradyk]

I love him, but we really need to be going after Turpin. If we don't get Turpin it could be an alternative instead of keeping Lichaa. Reynolds' body is towards the end of his career tho.

 

[Nasheed]

Why not Farah?
Old sure, but has creativity and cunning. Don’t think tigers want him. Cheap for a year and reassess 2021. Nasheed.

 

[Raikkonen]

Pls no

 

[Scoooby]

NO THANK YOU..

It’s time for a new era, time to move on..!!!

 

[Kiwipup]

Absolutely!

Would be a godsend to instil grit into the majority of the puppies in our squad

Club should jump on it ASAP as Tigers will be forced to pay a major chunk of his salary