Out of interest what is your definition of fail?
He did have a 57% win rate, 5 final series in a row and 2 grand finals.
Football is a form of entertainment...It's a fail if you don't
Struggling to win ugly under the pretense of being under the radar...is a fail
Preventing the team celebrating after making the grand final 2012...is a fail
Destroying our first and lower grades rosters by keeping the wrong players and pushing out the good loyal players...is a fail
We were minor premiers in all grades in 2012...what happened since is a fail
Overpaying his favorite players...is a fail
Not recognizing new talent
eg. L. Mitchell, C. Watson, C. Munster, M. Moses, D. Cook...is a fail
Persisting on playing the ugliest and most boring football style in the games history...is a fail
Deceiving the club that financially rewarded him and fans that treated and respected him like no other...
Is the greatest fail !!!
Maybe these are old values that means nothing to some but means a lot to me...This is why he lost my respect !!!