Bulldogs vs Souths - Your Player Ratings

Status
Not open for further replies.
JORDZILLA

JORDZILLA

Kennel Addict
Joined
Mar 9, 2013
Messages
5,292
Reaction score
3,563
Bulldogs vs Souths - Your Player Ratings

1. Sam Perrett - 6
2. Corey Thompson - 5
3. Josh Morris - 2
4. Tim Lafai - 4
5. Mitch Brown - 3
6. Josh Reynolds - 5
7. Trent Hodkinson 1
8. Aiden Tolman 6
9. Moses Mbye 6
10. James Graham 8
11. Josh Jackson 4
12. Tony Williams 7
13. Greg Eastwood 5

14. Tim Browne 4
15. Dale Finucane 5
16. David Klemmer 5
17. Frank Pritchard 6​
 
Agree with most of your ratings. Though I would probably give Eastwood a 7 or 8. Thought he was outstanding. Hit hard all night and tried his arse off.
 
Eastwood was outstanding ,trex was terrible id say 5
 
some people think williams was horrible,some think he was one of our best. I think he was our only player that looked dangerous, ffs how hard is it to support him Morris?
 
JORDZILLA said:
Bulldogs vs Souths - Your Player Ratings

1. Sam Perrett - 6
2. Corey Thompson - 5
3. Josh Morris - 2
4. Tim Lafai - 4
5. Mitch Brown - 3
6. Josh Reynolds - 5
7. Trent Hodkinson 1
8. Aiden Tolman 6
9. Moses Mbye 6
10. James Graham 8
11. Josh Jackson 4
12. Tony Williams 7
13. Greg Eastwood 5

14. Tim Browne 4
15. Dale Finucane 5
16. David Klemmer 5
17. Frank Pritchard 6​
Click to expand...

Happy with this. I would give mbye a bump to 6.5. A must off the bench next year.
 
Marley said:
some people think williams was horrible,some think he was one of our best. I think he was our only player that looked dangerous, ffs how hard is it to support him Morris?
Click to expand...

Agree. 5 tackle breaks. Where the fuk was Morris?
 
It is unfair to give hodkinson a 1... I am fairly certain he didn't take the field?
 
No a 1 is perfect for hod, that's the number of legs the bloke was out there on.

I know no one cares about should of would of could of, but we were ****ing unlucky to have both our 7 and 9 injured in the run up to a grand final.
 
Finucane (in defence), Williams (for effort mostly), Klemmer (effort), Eastwood, Graham and Tolman can hold their heads high. Rest were no where to be seen.
 
I think Reynolds deserves more than a 5. He tried his arse off, got us a 40/20, almost got us another try (grubber through for Williams), got a few repeat sets, and ran at the line.

Hokko deserves more than a 1 - yeah he was missing for most of the game, but he did set up Williams' try and had a few good kicks down field.

We lost due to lack of leadership, a critical position being filled by a player who is not used to playing there, and the simple fact that the bunnies wanted it more. I also don't thing that it is fair to grade our players - especially when some people hold personal biases against a member of the team that they SUPPORT.
 
I think considering we came from 7th, were missing our captain in the 2nd/3rd most crucial position and our HB was on 1 leg we should forget the player ratings.

Losing a GF hurts but its not like we charged into the GF on form, we limped in on heart. Just be proud to go for a club that demands respect.
 
Does anyone know if Tim Lafai was injured during the game? Someone mentioned he injured his ankle about 10 mins in.
 
Wolfmother said:
Does anyone know if Tim Lafai was injured during the game? Someone mentioned he injured his ankle about 10 mins in.
Click to expand...

I recall he got up very gingerly about that time, and I thought he was gone.
 
Abdul.. said:
I recall he got up very gingerly about that time, and I thought he was gone.
Click to expand...

Wouldnt be surprised... It is the GF. Every player is carrying some injury or another.
 
Kratos said:
I think considering we came from 7th, were missing our captain in the 2nd/3rd most crucial position and our HB was on 1 leg we should forget the player ratings.

Losing a GF hurts but its not like we charged into the GF on form, we limped in on heart. Just be proud to go for a club that demands respect.
Click to expand...


Man, well said champ... those words demand respect
 
Marley said:
some people think williams was horrible,some think he was one of our best. I think he was our only player that looked dangerous, ffs how hard is it to support him Morris?
Click to expand...

He was hot and cold. At times he ran hard. Other times flat footed. ****ed up early when he dropped that pass from Trent when he was running a decoy, should have expected it, and threw a couple of stupid passes that led to turnovers. One on the third tackle in our third set attacking their line when it looked like we would score. Thought he would have a big game after the last few weeks. Disappointing. As were the rest of the team
 
Croc said:
He was hot and cold. At times he ran hard. Other times flat footed. ****ed up early when he dropped that pass from Trent when he was running a decoy, should have expected it, and threw a couple of stupid passes that led to turnovers. One on the third tackle in our third set attacking their line when it looked like we would score. Thought he would have a big game after the last few weeks. Disappointing. As were the rest of the team
Click to expand...

One of them was a good pass to Morris, who dropped a sitter.
 
marley said:
some people think williams was horrible,some think he was one of our best. I think he was our only player that looked dangerous, ffs how hard is it to support him morris?
Click to expand...

x2
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top