• Be cool and Register to set your username and display picture get the full features of the site. Talk Bulldogs NRL News, match reviews, live score, ladder, injuries, player signings and team performance.

News Bulldogs could be denied salary cap relief for Kieran Foran injury!

Pity Fool

Kennel Regular
Gilded
Joined
Nov 22, 2017
Messages
732
Reaction score
413
Well well well, isn’t this a surprise? How typical of the NRL to deny us relief yet Souths most likely get salary cap relief for Sam Burgess when he is on over a million per season and his contract doesn’t end until 2022! Both are pending but I wouldn’t be surprised for Souths to approved for his full sum and us not even getting $350k relief!
 

Ant2611

Kennel Regular
Joined
Aug 4, 2009
Messages
422
Reaction score
194
Well well well, isn’t this a surprise? How typical of the NRL to deny us relief yet Souths most likely get salary cap relief for Sam Burgess when he is on over a million per season and his contract doesn’t end until 2022! Both are pending but I wouldn’t be surprised for Souths to approved for his full sum and us not even getting $350k relief!
What proof makes you believe this to be the case?
 

Scoooby

Kennel Immortal
Premium Member
Gilded
Joined
Mar 6, 2018
Messages
8,368
Reaction score
5,251
The circus is in full swing an keeps getting even more silly by the second..!! Whatever happens, Wont surprise tbh.
 

Dognacious

Administrator
Staff member
Premium Member
Gilded
Joined
Aug 4, 2007
Messages
17,847
Reaction score
2,772
Source?

And if it's true, Sam is actually retired, and Foran isn't yet so...
 

DinkumDog

Kennel Addict
Gilded x2
Gilded
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,921
Reaction score
2,374
The Terrorgraph?

a) Few RL stories in December...
b) The cricket is very one-sided...
c) Grain of salt time...
 

Pity Fool

Kennel Regular
Gilded
Joined
Nov 22, 2017
Messages
732
Reaction score
413
The Terrorgraph?

a) Few RL stories in December...
b) The cricket is very one-sided...
c) Grain of salt time...
Indeed it was the Terrorgraph! Their stories don’t hold much weight with me, however, Paul Crawley wrote the article and he has more substance than other journo’s from that rag ie Rothfield etc imo!
 

Horse

Kennel Immortal
Gilded
Joined
Apr 16, 2006
Messages
5,184
Reaction score
1,672
Farcical. But 350k is just about as good as nil as substitute for a 1.2M marquee player, so I’m not bothered.

Great opportunity for Jack to cement his place as our little General #7. Lewis/Wakeham/Averillo to battle it out to play second fiddle.

It’ll be good for these young blokes to string some games together without Foran floating in and out of the team.
 

DinkumDog

Kennel Addict
Gilded x2
Gilded
Joined
May 15, 2017
Messages
3,921
Reaction score
2,374
Indeed it was the Terrorgraph! Their stories don’t hold much weight with me, however, Paul Crawley wrote the article and he has more substance than other journo’s from that rag ie Rothfield etc imo!
Fair call mate but at the end of the day the Terrorgraph are known more for their fiction writing than anything else. Considering the time of year and not much else going on sport wise, I wouldn’t buy too much into this unless a credible source emerges. Cheers.
 

Pity Fool

Kennel Regular
Gilded
Joined
Nov 22, 2017
Messages
732
Reaction score
413
What proof makes you believe this to be the case?
There is no proof mate, it’s just a news story written by Paul Crawley. Was worthy of a thread due to our current predicament with Foran and the status quo of the game in general where some teams are given certain privileges and others aren’t. Like I stated “ both cases are pending” but wouldn’t be surprised if we were duded in the process!
 

Jackson_1994

Kennel Regular
Joined
Oct 28, 2018
Messages
517
Reaction score
761
In a predicament that exposes an unfairness in the NRL’s system for salary cap relief, the Bulldogs could be penalised despite losing Kieran Foran to a shoulder injury while playing for New Zealand.
Kieran Foran is so hellbent on recovering from his recent shoulder surgery that he could cost Canterbury any salary cap relief.

In a predicament that exposes a glaring unfairness in the NRL’s system, the Bulldogs could be penalised for Foran’s determination to recover from the shocking injury he suffered while playing for New Zealand.

While it was initially feared he could miss all of next season, Foran is telling people close to him that he has set himself a target to be back playing by June at the latest, but possibly at some stage in May.

Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, clubs are only entitled to a maximum of $350,000 in cap relief for a player injured while on representative duty if the player has been sidelined for at least 12 NRL games.

Foran’s timeline would potentially have him back on the field just before that period elapses, meaning the Bulldogs would be out of pocket unless there was an immediate change to the guidelines.

The Bulldogs are expected to appeal to the NRL that regardless of when Foran returns they should still be entitled to the maximum salary cap relief.

The club is expected to get the surgeon’s final report this week and present it to the NRL.

The determination will set a precedent given no other club has yet qualified for the representative injury relief.

Canberra missed out when Jordan Rapana returned to the field just short of the 12-match cut-off.

The Bulldogs would argue that all indications from medical experts were that Foran was facing a minimum of six months on the sideline but possibly as many as 10
It seems ludicrous that the limit is capped at $350,000 for all players, especially when Foran is the Bulldogs’ highest- paid player on $1.2 million.

He was also fit and healthy when he left for Kiwi camp but returned home requiring two shoulder operations.

There is no disputing when the injury occurred given it happened in front of everyone watching the Test.

It would also seem unfair to make a club wait until June to find out if it qualifies for salary cap relief. By then, it would probably be too late to spend the money in next year’s cap.

Foran has every reason to be pushing himself to get back early given he is off contract at the end of next season and will be fighting for his future.

He is 29 but has indicated he has no plan to retire any time soon. The football he played this year was proof that, when fit, he is still up with the NRL’s elite playmakers

That's the article
 

Pity Fool

Kennel Regular
Gilded
Joined
Nov 22, 2017
Messages
732
Reaction score
413
In a predicament that exposes an unfairness in the NRL’s system for salary cap relief, the Bulldogs could be penalised despite losing Kieran Foran to a shoulder injury while playing for New Zealand.
Kieran Foran is so hellbent on recovering from his recent shoulder surgery that he could cost Canterbury any salary cap relief.

In a predicament that exposes a glaring unfairness in the NRL’s system, the Bulldogs could be penalised for Foran’s determination to recover from the shocking injury he suffered while playing for New Zealand.

While it was initially feared he could miss all of next season, Foran is telling people close to him that he has set himself a target to be back playing by June at the latest, but possibly at some stage in May.

Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, clubs are only entitled to a maximum of $350,000 in cap relief for a player injured while on representative duty if the player has been sidelined for at least 12 NRL games.

Foran’s timeline would potentially have him back on the field just before that period elapses, meaning the Bulldogs would be out of pocket unless there was an immediate change to the guidelines.

The Bulldogs are expected to appeal to the NRL that regardless of when Foran returns they should still be entitled to the maximum salary cap relief.

The club is expected to get the surgeon’s final report this week and present it to the NRL.

The determination will set a precedent given no other club has yet qualified for the representative injury relief.

Canberra missed out when Jordan Rapana returned to the field just short of the 12-match cut-off.

The Bulldogs would argue that all indications from medical experts were that Foran was facing a minimum of six months on the sideline but possibly as many as 10
It seems ludicrous that the limit is capped at $350,000 for all players, especially when Foran is the Bulldogs’ highest- paid player on $1.2 million.

He was also fit and healthy when he left for Kiwi camp but returned home requiring two shoulder operations.

There is no disputing when the injury occurred given it happened in front of everyone watching the Test.

It would also seem unfair to make a club wait until June to find out if it qualifies for salary cap relief. By then, it would probably be too late to spend the money in next year’s cap.

Foran has every reason to be pushing himself to get back early given he is off contract at the end of next season and will be fighting for his future.

He is 29 but has indicated he has no plan to retire any time soon. The football he played this year was proof that, when fit, he is still up with the NRL’s elite playmakers

That's the article
Cheers mate!
 

bradyk

Kennel Addict
Joined
Mar 24, 2019
Messages
4,664
Reaction score
1,484
I don't think they're going to change the rules for us (I don't actually know what the rule is). Whatever the rules state is what we should get and that's the same for any club. I don't necessarily agree with the ruling (assuming it's capped at 350k) especially for a marquee player on his last year expected to be out for all (?) of the season. To prevent a loophole maybe they could make it as long as we agree to not re-sign Foran after 2020 that we could get the 1.2m in full...
 

doggieaaron

Super Moderator
Staff member
Joined
Nov 11, 2011
Messages
12,429
Reaction score
4,562
Foran will come back early and then get injured again fucken dumb fuck seriously kieran we love your heart but turn your fucking brain on
 

BEAST MODE

Previously Sancho2020
Gilded
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
33,684
Reaction score
15,707
In a predicament that exposes an unfairness in the NRL’s system for salary cap relief, the Bulldogs could be penalised despite losing Kieran Foran to a shoulder injury while playing for New Zealand.
Kieran Foran is so hellbent on recovering from his recent shoulder surgery that he could cost Canterbury any salary cap relief.

In a predicament that exposes a glaring unfairness in the NRL’s system, the Bulldogs could be penalised for Foran’s determination to recover from the shocking injury he suffered while playing for New Zealand.

While it was initially feared he could miss all of next season, Foran is telling people close to him that he has set himself a target to be back playing by June at the latest, but possibly at some stage in May.

Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, clubs are only entitled to a maximum of $350,000 in cap relief for a player injured while on representative duty if the player has been sidelined for at least 12 NRL games.

Foran’s timeline would potentially have him back on the field just before that period elapses, meaning the Bulldogs would be out of pocket unless there was an immediate change to the guidelines.

The Bulldogs are expected to appeal to the NRL that regardless of when Foran returns they should still be entitled to the maximum salary cap relief.

The club is expected to get the surgeon’s final report this week and present it to the NRL.

The determination will set a precedent given no other club has yet qualified for the representative injury relief.

Canberra missed out when Jordan Rapana returned to the field just short of the 12-match cut-off.

The Bulldogs would argue that all indications from medical experts were that Foran was facing a minimum of six months on the sideline but possibly as many as 10
It seems ludicrous that the limit is capped at $350,000 for all players, especially when Foran is the Bulldogs’ highest- paid player on $1.2 million.

He was also fit and healthy when he left for Kiwi camp but returned home requiring two shoulder operations.

There is no disputing when the injury occurred given it happened in front of everyone watching the Test.

It would also seem unfair to make a club wait until June to find out if it qualifies for salary cap relief. By then, it would probably be too late to spend the money in next year’s cap.

Foran has every reason to be pushing himself to get back early given he is off contract at the end of next season and will be fighting for his future.

He is 29 but has indicated he has no plan to retire any time soon. The football he played this year was proof that, when fit, he is still up with the NRL’s elite playmakers

That's the article
F U C K
O
R
A
N
 

JackDog

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Sep 24, 2016
Messages
1,887
Reaction score
979
In a predicament that exposes an unfairness in the NRL’s system for salary cap relief, the Bulldogs could be penalised despite losing Kieran Foran to a shoulder injury while playing for New Zealand.
Kieran Foran is so hellbent on recovering from his recent shoulder surgery that he could cost Canterbury any salary cap relief.

In a predicament that exposes a glaring unfairness in the NRL’s system, the Bulldogs could be penalised for Foran’s determination to recover from the shocking injury he suffered while playing for New Zealand.

While it was initially feared he could miss all of next season, Foran is telling people close to him that he has set himself a target to be back playing by June at the latest, but possibly at some stage in May.

Unfortunately for the Bulldogs, clubs are only entitled to a maximum of $350,000 in cap relief for a player injured while on representative duty if the player has been sidelined for at least 12 NRL games.

Foran’s timeline would potentially have him back on the field just before that period elapses, meaning the Bulldogs would be out of pocket unless there was an immediate change to the guidelines.

The Bulldogs are expected to appeal to the NRL that regardless of when Foran returns they should still be entitled to the maximum salary cap relief.

The club is expected to get the surgeon’s final report this week and present it to the NRL.

The determination will set a precedent given no other club has yet qualified for the representative injury relief.

Canberra missed out when Jordan Rapana returned to the field just short of the 12-match cut-off.

The Bulldogs would argue that all indications from medical experts were that Foran was facing a minimum of six months on the sideline but possibly as many as 10
It seems ludicrous that the limit is capped at $350,000 for all players, especially when Foran is the Bulldogs’ highest- paid player on $1.2 million.

He was also fit and healthy when he left for Kiwi camp but returned home requiring two shoulder operations.

There is no disputing when the injury occurred given it happened in front of everyone watching the Test.

It would also seem unfair to make a club wait until June to find out if it qualifies for salary cap relief. By then, it would probably be too late to spend the money in next year’s cap.

Foran has every reason to be pushing himself to get back early given he is off contract at the end of next season and will be fighting for his future.

He is 29 but has indicated he has no plan to retire any time soon. The football he played this year was proof that, when fit, he is still up with the NRL’s elite playmakers

That's the article
Sooo would it be so hard for the NRL to tell the dogs they can have the $350k cap relief now on the proviso that Foran cannot play for first 12 rounds even if he makes some miracle recovery and is available before then?

Then if the dogs did play Foz before rd13, the $350k relief would be null and void and the extra player signed would no longer be registered by the NRL to play.

This chance that Foz plays before rd13 are slim to none anyway, if he did he’d likely re-injure himself anyway
 

NPC83

Kennel Enthusiast
Gilded
Joined
Jul 9, 2019
Messages
1,374
Reaction score
708
I think the club doctor has to hold back on his clearance until after round 12... $350k is the least we should get. The rule should be changed to half the players salary. If a player is on $600k for example they would still get $350k in the exact same circumstances?
 

Trafford10

Kennel Addict
Gilded
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
4,077
Reaction score
2,404
I don't think they're going to change the rules for us (I don't actually know what the rule is). Whatever the rules state is what we should get and that's the same for any club. I don't necessarily agree with the ruling (assuming it's capped at 350k) especially for a marquee player on his last year expected to be out for all (?) of the season. To prevent a loophole maybe they could make it as long as we agree to not re-sign Foran after 2020 that we could get the 1.2m in full...
Hang on.
You say "that's the rule, same for any club"
Then you say to "prevent a loophole" we agree not to resign Foron for 2021 and we get the full $1.2m.
Isn't that the very definition of a loophole?
 
Last edited:

Trafford10

Kennel Addict
Gilded
Joined
Jun 26, 2015
Messages
4,077
Reaction score
2,404
Seriously what a nothing bullshit article based on ifs & maybes. Rugby league journalism (oxymoron right there) at it's usual pathetic low.

More interesting is the Souffs situation.
They got the NRL to agree to "medically retire" Inglis for being a habitual drunkard and now looking to medically retire Sam Burgess also.

Burgess maybe a much more legitimate case than Inglis. However my understanding is that no claim has been put to the insurance underwriter CGU with respect to Inglis?

I assume Souffs just paid him out the remainder of his contract and the NRL just subtracted that from Souffs salary cap?
 
Last edited:
Top