40,000 years and accomplished what? Human sacrifices? Over hunting leading to many animal species going extinct? Never able to do proper art work, couldn’t invent anything to push a civilisation forward?
A boat filled with white people, brought Christianity and Christian values building the west, brought medicine albeit also the flu killing many unintended people but that’s just nature, hospitals, universities, medicine, civilised civilisation, no human sacrifices, no hunting lands dry.
The 40,000 year old uncivilised civilisation would win hands down based on those facts.