yes David Penna, better player the coach.... he was a very average player! (thats a compliment!)Is our attacking coach the same bloke who was in the Des setup? Nothing changes after the first ten mins.
I'm not expecting him to turn us into a final team, i'm expecting him to make changes and improve the side like a coach is meant to do. Why the fuck do you lot need to bounce from one extreme to the other?You are expecting him to turn our bunch of juniors and fringe players into a finals team in 1 season, with no money to spend. Not unreasonable at all.
Yep more rookies with no experienceDon't worry Coggers on the way.
Hes tried a lot of players but he has a pretty ordinary bunch to choose from in the 30, which he can do fk all about this year. The options are worse playersI'm not expecting him to turn us into a final team, i'm expecting him to make changes and improve the side like a coach is meant to do. Why the fuck do you lot need to bounce from one extreme to the other?
His not good where he is... he missed a few tackles tonight normally is ok but not a half at all. Cant kick either kicks are uselessI think JMK is our new Mbye
I take that back actually, he does put the effort in... Lewis' effort was 100% again and has a good kicking game... I wouldn't mind seeing JMK at hooker, Brown in the halves with Lachy, as somebody has suggestedHis not good where he is... he missed a few tackles tonight normally is ok but not a half at all. Cant kick either kicks are useless
Well Pay if you want to keep your job beyond next season maybe a new coach instead of David would be a good start.yes David Penna, better player the coach.... he was a very average player! (thats a compliment!)
This thread is not about Pay.. I cant be sure how good he is or isnt as our team is rubbish on paper.. I just dont agree with persisting with JMK and Lewis together maybe keep one but not not both startingLook if Pay gets an offseason with a 30 he has put together and we are still doing poorly during next season, i will be giving him plenty then. My opinion that i am not judging Pay this year won't change, coz he isnt going to able to do any more about it before its over except experiment and sort the keepers from the throw backs.
Yes i like jmk at hooker but not where he is nowI take that back actually, he does put the effort in... Lewis' effort was 100% again and has a good kicking game... I wouldn't mind seeing JMK at hooker, Brown in the halves with Lachy, as somebody has suggested
Completely agree. No amount of coaching is gonna transform players who aren't really first grade standard yet. Perfect example is brodie croft at the storm. Bellamy is regarded as a supercoach but his coaching still couldn't help the fact that the kid wasn't ready for first grade yet.Change them for what? $1 coins.
WTF do you expect from 2 halves that have a dozen FG games between them? Lewis can count his FG games on 1 hand. FFS. What option has Pay got, Des spent our halves money on Foran. You have to be on meth if you think Cleeland will change anything, hes got no FG experience either and less talent than Lewis or JMK.
Lewis would be ok with an experienced half while he learns. He certainly has potential but is green. Both tries tonight are attributed to him, even though it was more JMK, Lewis got the missed tackle on their first try, and then Lewis kicks it into their legs for the other. But he also did good things. Rocks and diamonds, LIKE HOW MOST ROOKIES START OUT.
People are just reacting to losses, but not understanding why they are happening, and blaming the wrong people. Its STILL Des' fault ppl. Will be all year.
Like most threads currently though it did include Pay lol. Thats just it, how can we judge him based on what he was handed this year, which has only gotten harder with players going. Both of Des' starting halves for this year are gone for weeks now. Foran may or may not come back and be useful, but we would have the least experienced halves combo in the league. And an ordinary hooker. The spine is fragile this year.This thread is not about Pay.. I cant be sure how good he is or isnt as our team is rubbish on paper.. I just dont agree with persisting with JMK and Lewis together maybe keep one but not not both starting
Our seasons over but We still want to win a game or 2 to avoid the spoon
Lewis stays, JMK to hooker and Brown partnering Lewis in the halves. There’s no point bringing Cleeland up since he is not going to be in the clubs plans, I believe. Then again, neither should Pay be in the clubs plans.Not having a go at JMK or Lewis I would change at least one of them.
Try Nu Brown or do what we have to do to bring Cleeland in. This is going to be torture persisting with this for 8 weeks.
The OP did not mention Pay or the coach? Theres plenty of other Pay threadsLike most threads currently though it did include Pay lol. Thats just it, how can we judge him based on what he was handed this year, which has only gotten harder with players going. Both of Des' starting halves for this year are gone for weeks now. Foran may or may not come back and be useful, but we would have the least experienced halves combo in the league. And an ordinary hooker. The spine is fragile this year.