Hmmm.
Is this is not a fan forum?
Is this not a place where we can all discuss opinions and have different ones at that?
No need to be smug about it. I just personally think he offers nothing in attack, nothing in D, is not a noted speedster, and fails to provide any spark. Just remember - Baz called him an "out and out fullback" in the pre-season... and he got first dibs at it. How did he go? You could argue it was in a shit team - and how good was he when he was at the Rabbitohs. Sure - good argument. My rebuttal to that is he was working off the back of Cody Walker, who was operating at damn near Hayne-09 spec to finish off last year.
He was the QLD fullback, sure... 4th string. Ponga, Holmes, Brimson all ahead of him. He is 23 - so you might say age is on his side. But nothing I have seen of him in Dogs colours would suggest he is a long, medium or short term solution for us. He is just another very fringe first grader.