Opinion Who would you keep of the off Contract 15 (Poll)

[GDR]

Who would you Keep and Why ?

If i had to choose only one, it would be Atoni, i feel that he is the right style of Prop for the new rules . he is also most likely to break a game open..

Poll will only allow me to have 10..

I left Britt, Chrichton, Roumanous, Tui Katoa and Harding out of the poll, because i expect them to have the least amount of votes..

 

[Spoonman84]

Renouf and Okonbur even then they are both being signed on potential unless they step up this year.

If Atoni doesn’t become a genuine NRL prop this year I don’t think he ever will. His trial form looked good so I’m confident he will take the next step this year.

Okunbor on a low contract is a good signing. He is a big body who is still a rough diamond. If he signs for under $200k it’s a low risk for potential big return on investment. He does seem to genuinely love the club too despite his mistake last year.

The rest can’t get in the bin quick enough. It’s the ultimate collection of deadwood apart from Ogden depending on what he does this year.

 

[GDR]

Renouf and Okonbur even then they are both being signed on potential unless they step up this year.

If Atoni doesn’t become a genuine NRL prop this year I don’t think he ever will. His trial form looked good so I’m confident he will take the next step this year.

Okunbor on a low contract is a good signing. He is a big body who is still a rough diamond. If he signs for under $200k it’s a low risk for potential big return on investment. He does seem to genuinely love the club too despite his mistake last year.

The rest can’t get in the bin quick enough. It’s the ultimate collection of deadwood apart from Ogden depending on what he does this year.

Yeah I'd like to keep okunbor also and yeah both Atoni and okunbor are based on potential only. They both really need to step up this year...

 

[Kempsey Dog]

Would keep: Atoni (beast), Meaney and Okunbur for wing depth and keep reserve grade competitive if that's where they play.

Jury still out on Hoppa pending Schoupp and Alomati development.

Ogden whilst he does some big hits, I really don't think we need him with the new rule changes

 

[Dawain87]

Atoni is the only one on there provided he keeps fits and injury free to be offered a new contract -
Okunbor would be my other pick to keep on.

To be fair to the others, they all need to lift to another level if we are going to keep them on.

 

[mr j]

Ogden has knocked back a $225k extension offer

 

[TwinTurbo]

Hopoate, he is easily the best player on that list.

Go Dogs

 

[Freakzilla]

Atoni & Ogden. Get rid of the rest.

 

[wendog33]

Renouf, Ok.

Ofa if he kicks on. He's lucky to get offered $225K based on past inconsistent performances. You can see he has the potential but been too lazy so far. He looks a lot fitter and if he has knocked back 225K then he might be a bit more determined to back himself to succeed this year. Up to him.

Those wanting Meaney...he is supposed to be on 300K. How much do you think he should be on if re-signed?

Hoppa, as well as the rest, under no circumstances for me.

It is time to bring in younger, faster, more robust players who can do a job, better than average, for the whole team and the coach.

 

[TwinTurbo]

Who would you Keep and Why ?
If i had to choose only one, it would be Atoni, i feel that he is the right style of Prop for the new rules . he is also most likely to break a game open..
Poll will only allow me to have 10..
I left Britt, Chrichton, Roumanous, Tui Katoa and Harding out of the poll, because i expect them to have the least amount of votes..

You are propping up your own preference by placing them first, the donkey vote always ticks the first box.

Go Dogs

 

[vegny]

Antoni and okunbor. They have shown potential they can develop into good players in their position.
Hoppa. At least for short term until alamoti or schoupp ready for nrl.

 

[wendog33]

You are propping up your own preference by placing them first, the donkey vote always ticks the first box.

Go Dogs

We're Bulldogs: not Donkeys from Brisbane.

We can competently evaluate our top choice between 10 players, no matter where they are on the list!

Give us that bit of credit!

For heavens sake. You are turning into a TK nitpicker to rival Dawg

 

[GDR]

You are propping up your own preference by placing them first, the donkey vote always ticks the first box.

Go Dogs

Lol.. I copied it directly from zero tackle.. when I realized I could not put the whole 15 I had to remove some names and replace them with more likely players.

 

[TwinTurbo]

We're Bulldogs: not Donkeys from Brisbane.
We can competently evaluate our top choice between 10 players, no matter where they are on the list!
Give us that bit of credit!
For heavens sake. You are turning into a TK nitpicker to rival Dawg

Obviously I wasn't referring to you Wendy, but there are some ............

Go Dogs

 

[TwinTurbo]

Lol.. I copied it directly from zero tackle.. when I realized I could not put the whole 15 I had to remove some names and replace them with more likely players.

Some people have no sense of humour, maybe I need to use the large winking emoji ...............


Go Dogs

 

[hoody06]

My take on 2022.

Contracted for 22 (14 players)

Wakeham, Allan, DWZ, Averillo, Flanagan, Cotric, Elliott, Waddell, Hethrington, Stimson, Jackson, Thompson, Doorey, RFM.

Signings so far (2)
JAC, Burton

Likely elevation top 30 (4)
Schoup, Topine, Alamoti, Dietz

Depth signings and likely re-signings (6)

Okunbur, Tui Katoa, C.Smith, JMK, Ogden, Atoni

That's a total of 26 players leaving 4 further external signings available.

You simply can't go out and sign 15 players, doesn't work that way.

 

[GDR]

Hopoate, he is easily the best player on that list.

Go Dogs

Some people have no sense of humour, maybe I need to use the large winking emoji ...............
View attachment 21678

Go Dogs

Your joke about Hoppa being the best player on that list was way funnier..

 

[CaptainJackson]

Renouf and Okonbur even then they are both being signed on potential unless they step up this year.

If Atoni doesn’t become a genuine NRL prop this year I don’t think he ever will. His trial form looked good so I’m confident he will take the next step this year.

Okunbor on a low contract is a good signing. He is a big body who is still a rough diamond. If he signs for under $200k it’s a low risk for potential big return on investment. He does seem to genuinely love the club too despite his mistake last year.

The rest can’t get in the bin quick enough. It’s the ultimate collection of deadwood apart from Ogden depending on what he does this year.

Came in to say exactly this ^

Renouf, Okunbur and Ogden depending on how he goes this year.

There's no one else what-so-ever that will do a job moving forward.

The only one other maybe is JMK as 3rd choice hooker option, as long as we sign 2 more.

 

[CaptainJackson]

I think this also shows how much garbage we still have on the roster.

 

[TwinTurbo]

Your joke about Hoppa being the best player on that list was way funnier..

As at today he is absolutely the best player on the list (note, no winking emoji).

Go Dogs