Who would you honestly keep from our 17

Some doggies supporter

Some doggies supporter

Kennel Participant
Joined
Oct 29, 2018
Messages
107
Reaction score
153
1- Nick Meaney: Like the kid there is potential
2-Samoan Sauce: Strong runner but is if when it comes to a high ball
3-Montoya: Has had his second wind resign him on a 1 year deal if form continues
4-Hoppa: Fuck off. Really offers nothing
5-Reimis Smith: I feeling sorry for the kid is a good player but stuck outside a pleb
6- Foran- Good on his day but inconsistent and injured most of the time
7-Cogger: Meh
8-Tolman: Loyal servant but holy shit needs to stop pretending his a half
9-JMK: Trades not run for slightly better pass than licher
10-Ofa: Need this kid
11- Jacko: Needs to play lock and strip him of the captaincy
12-Adam Eliot: Has nudes of pay
13- RFM:Hit or miss
Benchies- Put Renouf in it and then I don’t care who else
 
I reckon chrichton and monty could be good centres monty has been great
 
How the fuck can this side take up all our cap. Couldn’t beat a well under strength raiders team. We won’t beat the bye
 
CC
Ogden
Meaney
 
I look at it this way, how many of those players are winn8ng you a grand final in there respective positions
Maybe 3-5 in whole squad
 
Dakdah said:
How the fuck can this side take up all our cap. Couldn’t beat a well under strength raiders team. We won’t beat the bye
Click to expand...

It’s. Its not just this side taking up our cap. It’s this side + Woods + Mbye + Reynolds + all the other back ended contracts signed by the old administration and coach apparently!
 
Bullpit said:
It’s. Its not just this side taking up our cap. It’s this side + Woods + Mbye + Reynolds + all the other back ended contracts signed by the old administration and coach apparently!
Click to expand...
Woods and Reynolds are not currently been payed by our club. As for back ended deals no one other than the board knows.
 
in 4 to 5 years time probably only 2 to 3 of this squad will remain at the club. The rest will be reserve grade injury back up or if they got lucky super league
 
Meaney (pending weight gain)
Smith
Cogger
CHN
Ogden
Renouf
Lewis
Jackson (we should replace him with Arrow)
are the only players i really care about keeping in our top 30, everyone else is replaceable.
 
1. Hopoate (will offer more in attack at the back than Meaney)
2. Crichton
3. Montoya
4. Holland (his combo with Lewis and Reimis last year was awesome and seems to have been forgotten)
5. Smith
6. Foran
7. Lewis
8. Tolman
9. Liicha (sucks but still offers more than JMK)
10. Napa
11. Jackson
12. CHN
13. Martin

14. Elliott
15. Ogden
16. Sue
17. Cogger
 
Seem to me pays lost the dressing room the players can play the game but I don’t see their hearts in it their not putting in for the coach
 
In order of preference
1st - Ogden (we must keep him)
2nd - Toomaga (Much better than the others)
We can build a team around these 2.
3rd - Remis Smith (Needs to add weight)
4th - CHN (seen enough to know that good coaching will make him great)

The following are maybes

- Okunbor
- Napa
- Chris Smith (as a bench prop)
- Meany (but must offer more in attack than currently)

That's It
 
Matty said:
1. Hopoate (will offer more in attack at the back than Meaney)
2. Crichton
3. Montoya
4. Holland (his combo with Lewis and Reimis last year was awesome and seems to have been forgotten)
5. Smith
6. Foran
7. Lewis
8. Tolman
9. Liicha (sucks but still offers more than JMK)
10. Napa
11. Jackson
12. CHN
13. Martin

14. Elliott
15. Ogden
16. Sue
17. Cogger
Click to expand...

1. meaney
2. okunbor/montoya
3. hopoate
4. holland
5. smith
6. lewis
7. foran
8. tolman
9. marshall-king
10. napa/ogden
11. martin
12. jackson
13. elliott

14. harawira-naera
15. ogden/fualalo
16. fualalo/toomaga
17. sue
 
I'd honestly only keep: -

Smith
CHN
Ogden

The rest can go to the sewerage treatment plant.
 
We don’t have the luxury of choosing who we’d keep...no player in their right mind would come to replace any of the shit ***** we currently trot out each week
 
Players off contract this year - Fualalo, Tualau, Nu Brown, Lichaa, Martin, Harper, Katoa, John Olive

Would only re-sign Katoa for a couple of seasons to further develop in the lower grades.

Players off contract from other clubs this year which i would bring in - Scott Drinkwater, Christian Welch

To fill in the other 5 spots, search for some pommies in the ESL as well as players in QLD Cup.

If there is no luck than stardust circus and handpick one of many crazy clowns to replace Dean Pay
 
Sue said:
Players off contract this year - Fualalo, Tualau, Nu Brown, Lichaa, Martin, Harper, Katoa, John Olive

Would only re-sign Katoa for a couple of seasons to further develop in the lower grades.

Players off contract from other clubs this year which i would bring in - Scott Drinkwater, Christian Welch

To fill in the other 5 spots, search for some pommies in the ESL as well as players in QLD Cup.

If there is no luck than stardust circus and handpick one of many crazy clowns to replace Dean Pay
Click to expand...
Need to re sign Fualalo.
 
I’d keep:
Olive
Lichaa
Elliott
Hoppa
Tolman
JMK
Sue
Foran (6 mil for 5 years)
 
Kelpie03 said:
Woods and Reynolds are not currently been payed by our club. As for back ended deals no one other than the board knows.
Click to expand...

I think Woods and Mbye are still chewing around 150k each...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top