Opinion Who will replace DWZ

[Brendan07]

Katoa is average at best
Like Marcelo Montoya average
He makes Holland look like a star

Let’s not go that far! Holland was diabolical

 

[Brendan07]

Baz can play 5/8th can’t be any worse than Jake!

 

[DogsOfWar1704]

Harding could of been a option if he was 15-20 kilos heavier haha.
How is he 6'2 and only 78kg

 

[steve1700]

Dry track I'd keep avo at 5/8 just to see if he can hit his straps.
Tui katoa will most likely come in.
Wish we had oko back but.

When you say it like that makes sense.

 

[GDR]

Katoa is average at best
Like Marcelo Montoya average
He makes Holland look like a star

Yeah I agree.. I've seen nothing from Tui to suggest he's a first grader..

 

[GDR]

Replacing a winger with someone like Katoa, is the least of our problems

Sorry you must of misread the thread .. theres a thousand other threads for you to discuss other problems

 

[TroopSalute]

Sorry you must of misread the thread .. theres a thousand other threads for you to discuss other problems

Reason for my comment, is not attacking the player but the role of a winger in the team is way much simpler and less of a headache for the coach who has RFM out for 4 months and a bunch of forwards who are being run over and dominated....hope that clarifies that?

 

[GDR]

Reason for my comment, is not attacking the player but the role of a winger in the team is way much simpler and less of a headache for the coach who has RFM out for 4 months and a bunch of forwards who are being run over and dominated....hope that clarifies that?

no it doesn't tbh ... however now that you bring it up, RFM hasn't set the world on fire and looked a fair bit of the pace TBH.. so not a big issue.. he wont be missed based on what he provided so far in the first 2 games..

 

[Doggiezbrah]

I’d go cotric wing and schoupp centre

Can we apply for an exemption to have into our squad?

 

[bradyk]

+T. Katoa, Doorey and Smith
-DWZ, RFM and Katoa

I'd have Schoupp and Topine instead if they were in the top 30 (even Deitz possibly off the bench).

Our winger combination is going to be atrocious and we don't have one prop suited to starting.

 

[finchie]

Replacing a winger with someone like Katoa, is the least of our problems

Who’s going to take a the tough hit ups out from our own end
It sure ain’t going to be Meaney or floppa
Only cotric and allan

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Who’s going to take a the tough hit ups out from our own end
It sure ain’t going to be Meaney or floppa
Only cotric and allan

Allan lol, softer carries than Hoppa.

 

[jake6]

katoa

 

[finchie]

Let’s not go that far! Holland was diabolical

Very true
But diabolical with a touch of good in between

 

[TroopSalute]

Who’s going to take a the tough hit ups out from our own end
It sure ain’t going to be Meaney or floppa
Only cotric and allan

Sometimes things happen for a reason...players need to step up when they get the opportunity otherwise what the hell are they doing in the top 30 in the first place...yes Katoa may not provide or be as effective as Cotric but he is a winger and surely has other attributes to his game and if TBaz selects him, will have a role to play for the team.

 

[finchie]

Sometimes things happen for a reason...players need to step up when they get the opportunity otherwise what the hell are they doing in the top 30 in the first place...yes Katoa may not provide or be as effective as Cotric but he is a winger and surely has other attributes to his game and if TBaz selects him, will have a role to play for the team.

If Trent selects him it’s because we are down to our last standing winger

 

[TroopSalute]

If Trent selects him it’s because we are down to our last standing winger

... you forgot about Tyrone Harding

 

[Scoooby]

I don’t think it will make a lot of difference, maybe it will, maybe not.. time will tell on game day.

 

[justdogs]

View attachment 22317

much better player than DWZ

 

[DoggyStyla]

Does anyone actually have some insite to Katoa? As good as his brother?