The way I see it is, taking over a third division side and getting them promoted to the first division in consecutive years, and then challenging for the league in your first year in the bundesliga is a whole lot more impressive than taking over Bayern and winning the league, etc.
He was the person who identified the likes of Mane, Kimmich, Upamecano, Keita etc, and he had the foresight to sign Haaland even before he really exploded into the player he went on to become. He now has the keys to a scouting network bigger than all his previous clubs combined.
He has rejected offers from Chelsea and Spurs within the past year. He was close to signing for AC Milan until a dispute at the 12th hour. And we will never know if he was or wasnt the first choice for the job, but we do know our football director John Murtourgh went to Germany in 2019 to spend time with Rangnick, so he was admired by the club.
I agree with you regarding the promotion of football clubs , it’s the sign of a good coach and good work when a coach can take a take a club and advance them categories.
Klopp did this also with Mainz , but he then moved up the coaching ranks by testing and challenging himself at bigger clubs. Rangnick has never tested himself to date at a bigger club or a stronger league.
Many coaches would not reject the opportunity to work at clubs like Chelsea or Milan, but Ragnick apparently declined that challenge and only he knows why.
The names you mentioned that he scouted are all hardworking or strong players , there’s a pattern there and it’s indicative of the sort of players he wants in his team .
He’s had 2 spells at Schalke and was sacked the first time, he only won the cup so you can hardly consider his tenure successful if he got punted, with or without Raul up front. He also cited stress related issues during his tenure so if he could not handle the pressures of the German league good luck dealing with the demands of a club like Man Utd.
That’s probably why he’s only a caretaker until the end of the season and someone else will take over and he will move to non coaching position the following season.
Ronaldo will be safe with Rangnick this season , I just think his minutes will be reduced to get more longevity out of him. The following season though will be intersting what he does with him . Ronaldo will want to play, he always wants to play.
The one that should be worried is Bruno, he’s neither a physically strong player , nor has a motor on him and doesn’t really transition when the team defends. Surplus to requirements Im thinking .
Time will tell though , he may turn him around and get the best out of him but this season Bruno has been a flop.
The types of Sancho will definitely see more game time with Rangnick on the bench .