The Club needs a Clean out

[Mike Z]

We need a major clean out.
Our style of footy is not of a premiership team.
Our mix of players are too similar.
Tolman and Graham are too the same. Wanna be halves.
Eastwood is too predictable. Good in defense the same as Jackson.
Our hooker Liecha offers nothing compared to other hookers.
Kasiano tries hard but wants to be too fancy.
Our halves are playing restricted yet really they dont have any spontaneous instincs. They play too an act.
Our backline can finish a try but rarely create anything, more they get a result from poor opposition defence.
Finally the coach had a good resume but has not really made us better. Other teams are way more damaging.

We need one great hooker. One creative half and one big strong speedy centre and one old style hard prop to replace Tolman.

Thats just my opinion.

Mike Z

 

[Wahesh]

Apart from the Sharks, every other Sydney team is below us on the ladder. Relax.

 

[Heckler]

We need a major clean out.
Our style of footy is not of a premiership team.
Our mix of players are too similar.
Tolman and Graham are too the same. Wanna be halves.
Eastwood is too predictable. Good in defense the same as Jackson.
Our hooker Liecha offers nothing compared to other hookers.
Kasiano tries hard but wants to be too fancy.
Our halves are playing restricted yet really they dont have any spontaneous instincs. They play too an act.
Our backline can finish a try but rarely create anything, more they get a result from poor opposition defence.
Finally the coach had a good resume but has not really made us better. Other teams are way more damaging.

We need one great hooker. One creative half and one big strong speedy centre and one old style hard prop to replace Tolman.

Thats just my opinion.

Mike Z

Ok then. Heres your chance. If you're in charge of the clean out hypothetically speaking, name your squad and coach. Remember that you have to achieve better than what you already have.

Im happy with what we have.

 

[CrittaMagic69]

Our structure needs a revamp, i don't think we need a full on cleanout other than a few players being moved on and brought in.

 

[bringitontm]

I think we are fine at moment. Just need a replacement for Dorothy next year and maybe a new hooker. Last game no Hoppa. No Josh or Brett Morris, no Klemmer, no Jackson and Kasiano only lasted 10mins.

That the 6 best players in the team not playing. Looks how roosters went with their 6 best out.

 

[Klemhammer]

If we take out Salary cap cheats such as Broncos we are in the top 4

 

[Horny Wog]

1. Revamp our playing structure.

2. Dispose of Dorothy

3. Find another 1st grade backrower

 

[blueyedsamurai]

1. Revamp our playing structure.

2. Dispose of Dorothy

3. Find another 1st grade backrower

Number 2 is already done isn't it?

 

[Horny Wog]

Number 2 is already done isn't it?

I hope so

 

[_G-Dog_]

We have severe curvature of the spine.
Addressing that would be a good start

 

[_G-Dog_]

Number 2 is already done isn't it?

Still on our cap but that alot of that cash is going to be used on upgrades I suspect

 

[Chrisaaar]

The way some are carrying on... It's as if we just lost to the knights with a full team by 50 points.

 

[Mr Invisible]

We are fine...

Address the inconsistencies who hold the whistle instead.

 

[Dognacious]

We need a major clean out.
Our style of footy is not of a premiership team.
Our mix of players are too similar.
Tolman and Graham are too the same. Wanna be halves.
Eastwood is too predictable. Good in defense the same as Jackson.
Our hooker Liecha offers nothing compared to other hookers.
Kasiano tries hard but wants to be too fancy.
Our halves are playing restricted yet really they dont have any spontaneous instincs. They play too an act.
Our backline can finish a try but rarely create anything, more they get a result from poor opposition defence.
Finally the coach had a good resume but has not really made us better. Other teams are way more damaging.

We need one great hooker. One creative half and one big strong speedy centre and one old style hard prop to replace Tolman.

Thats just my opinion.

Mike Z

/rant

 

[Izzy Forreal]

We have severe curvature of the spine.
Addressing that would be a good start

Very true. Although it will probably require major surgery to remove Graham and Tolman. Also a psychiatrist to gently inform our super coach of the value of attack in Rugby League.

I'll set myself up for ridicule here and name the seventeen I would prefer:

1 Hopoate
2 Rona
3 J Morris
4 Mbye (Has played centre and has gone exceptionally well)
5 Perrett (Sam usually has a mistake free day out)
6 Reynolds
7 Chisholm (Not brilliant but will back himself. Has a good short kicking game)
8 Klemmer
9 Lichaa
10 Graham (For the defence aspect of his game + hit ups. No more captain should bring more mongrel)
11 Jackson
12 Eastwood (c)
13 Garvey (Very strong and tough defender. Only get smart with the ball if the occasion is there)
__________________________________________________________________________________
14 Kasiano
15 Faitala-Mariner
16 Fualalo
17 Elliott

Tolman and Browne? Personally I think they've become toothless Bulldogs
Holland? His goal kicking has now become sometimes great other times shit. As a player just not good enough as a first grade centre. I think that is why Josh Jackson was playing there against theb Roosters

 

[Mitch Connor]

Very true. Although it will probably require major surgery to remove Graham and Tolman. Also a psychiatrist to gently inform our super coach of the value of attack in Rugby League.

I'll set myself up for ridicule here and name the seventeen I would prefer:

1 Hopoate
2 Rona
3 J Morris
4 Mbye (Has played centre and has gone exceptionally well)
5 Perrett (Sam usually has a mistake free day out)
6 Reynolds
7 Chisholm (Not brilliant but will back himself. Has a good short kicking game)
8 Klemmer
9 Lichaa
10 Graham (For the defence aspect of his game + hit ups. No more captain should bring more mongrel)
11 Jackson
12 Eastwood (c)
13 Garvey (Very strong and tough defender. Only get smart with the ball if the occasion is there)
__________________________________________________________________________________
14 Kasiano
15 Faitala-Mariner
16 Fualalo
17 Elliott

Tolman and Browne? Personally I think they've become toothless Bulldogs
Holland? His goal kicking has now become sometimes great other times shit. As a player just not good enough as a first grade centre. I think that is why Josh Jackson was playing there against theb Roosters

You see Garveys attempt on Tapine yesterday? Send him back to St George with a 'thanks, but no thanks' note.

 

[Tegga]

Very true. Although it will probably require major surgery to remove Graham and Tolman. Also a psychiatrist to gently inform our super coach of the value of attack in Rugby League.

I'll set myself up for ridicule here and name the seventeen I would prefer:

1 Hopoate
2 Rona
3 J Morris
4 Mbye (Has played centre and has gone exceptionally well)
5 Perrett (Sam usually has a mistake free day out)
6 Reynolds
7 Chisholm (Not brilliant but will back himself. Has a good short kicking game)
8 Klemmer
9 Lichaa
10 Graham (For the defence aspect of his game + hit ups. No more captain should bring more mongrel)
11 Jackson
12 Eastwood (c)
13 Garvey (Very strong and tough defender. Only get smart with the ball if the occasion is there)
__________________________________________________________________________________
14 Kasiano
15 Faitala-Mariner
16 Fualalo
17 Elliott

Tolman and Browne? Personally I think they've become toothless Bulldogs
Holland? His goal kicking has now become sometimes great other times shit. As a player just not good enough as a first grade centre. I think that is why Josh Jackson was playing there against theb Roosters

Garvey shouldn't be anywhere near our bench let alone a starting line up, has brain explosions and poor reads in defence unless he's in the middle.

 

[Mr Invisible]

Garvey is waaaaaaayy too short to play lock.

 

[Izzy Forreal]

You see Garveys attempt on Tapine yesterday? Send him back to St George with a 'thanks, but no thanks' note.

Garvey shouldn't be anywhere near our bench let alone a starting line up, has brain explosions and poor reads in defence unless he's in the middle.

Okay, that's Garvey sent to the gallows. How about the rest of 'em?

 

[D.O.W.]

I'm not sure on wholesale changes, it's not like we are strugglers, but yeah, in terms of having a roster that is a genuine premiership contender, we don't have it. Our spine is still the issue, Hopoate (every 3rd week), Reynolds, Mybe and Lichaa are major concerns. How can you compare to Coote, Morgan, Thurston, Granville or Boyd, Hunt, Milford, McCullough or Slater, Green, Cronk, Smith?