Opinion SOS Shane Flanagan

[Doggiezbrah]

I'd take Ciraldo but the talent pool is extremely thin.

I think its one of the things keeping Tbaz in a job.

I know he is highly regarded but is he another Barrett?

 

[Bazildog]

Everyone who wants Shane Flanagan pretends that having Kyle Flanagan at the club isn't a massive problem.

He is nowhere as a 7 but hopefully Gould is smart enough to sort any deal with Flanagan does not include his son.

 

[Dognacious]

Baz is a proven good assistant coach. Maybe he should be assistant to flanno. He hasn't shown signs of being a good head coach yet

 

[Gene Krupa]

I'd take Ciraldo but the talent pool is extremely thin.

I think its one of the things keeping Tbaz in a job.

I think, they are not knocking the doors down to apply.

 

[Dogmonster]

Ciraldo wont fix this mess.

 

[Bazildog]

Ciraldo with an experienced co coach/minder maybe, but no rookies or unproven coaches on thier own. Maybe Gould has to bite the bullet if we bring Ciraldo or Woolfe in to Co-coach for a season or so?

 

[Spoonman84]

I know he is highly regarded but is he another Barrett?

Is he the next Fitzgibbon? No one knows until they are given a shot.

Its a gamble but any new coaching appointment is.

 

[Dogmonster]

If Shane Flanagan was coach, and his son Kyle wasn't performing he would have to deal with it for his own reputation, just like Brad Arthur had too.

 

[diddly]

I'd take Ciraldo but the talent pool is extremely thin.

I think its one of the things keeping Tbaz in a job.

Barrett and his team are failing miserably and there are no excuses - id only contemplate Flanagan sen if Flanagan jun was moved or John Morris.

 

[Dogmonster]

Should buy Munster and get Shane Flanagan.
This would squeeze Kyle to Reserve grade .

 

[Teddybear]

Bellamy

 

[Teddybear]

Or no one else

 

[Spoonman84]

Barrett and his team are failing miserably and there are no excuses - id only contemplate Flanagan sen if Flanagan jun was moved or John Morris.

Kyle won't be going anywhere if Shane is the coach and no one else will be getting a look in at halfback.

 

[Dognacious]

Should buy Munster and get Shane Flanagan.
This would squeeze Kyle to Reserve grade .

Why? Munster is a 6. If u are going to pay Munster money u would want a specialist 7

 

[Dogmonster]

Why? Munster is a 6. If u are going to pay Munster money u would want a specialist 7

2 options, Munster Fullback he would coach a 7 what do, or Munster 7 and Burton 6.

 

[David holland]

Problem with Shane is Kyle his terrible

 

[Shanked]

no

 

[Dognacious]

2 options, Munster Fullback he would coach a 7 what do, or Munster 7 and Burton 6.

Nah. Too much money to have 2 x 6s...again. Id have taken Munster if we hadnt taken Burton, and had the money as well. Reynolds would have been better as a 7 for the same money.

 

[JackDog]

Why? Munster is a 6. If u are going to pay Munster money u would want a specialist 7

Who? Who is available?

Hunt or Brooks are the only “quality” halves available from November 1. Personally, never rated either for the cash they get. And neither dominates the game, they’d both turn to shit in our system.

Burton is playing like a half for us now, adding Munster to our spine would improve things immensely.

Won’t happen, he’ll either stay in Melbourne or go to Skeletor

 

[a dogs life]

Kyle won't be going anywhere if Shane is the coach and no one else will be getting a look in at halfback.

He’s a good coach but not the answer to our problems. Too much baggage and Kyle.