Regarding Josh Addo Carr

Should Josh Ado Carr be sacked?

  • Yes

    Votes: 151 48.7%
  • No

    Votes: 159 51.3%

  • Total voters
    310
Status
Not open for further replies.

King Gus

Kennel Addict
Joined
Jul 18, 2021
Messages
7,220
Reaction score
12,908
Heavily strapped, still not 100 percent after returning from injury and run down by one of the fastest guys in the comp. I think the end of an era assessment is a little exaggerated.

When he was on field this season he showed he’s still by far the best finisher in our team. I bet if we let him go he will really hurt us next year.
Just look at the game against manly if we had fox we would’ve won Skelton bombed a try which fox would’ve nailed and Skelton let in a try fox would’ve went for the interception.
 

Cappuccino

Kennel Legend
Joined
Aug 5, 2019
Messages
10,100
Reaction score
18,241
It’s actually almost two thirds who believe that according to the poll, but try telling that to the vocal minority who want to browbeat others for having a different opinion.

I do think Gus is trying to shove him out the door though, mate. If he wasn’t, he wouldn’t be allowing his press lackey to write negative articles questioning Fox’s commitment.
Brother when are you and twin turbo presenting the results of the poll to the board?
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
Heavily strapped, still not 100 percent after returning from injury and run down by one of the fastest guys in the comp. I think the end of an era assessment is a little exaggerated.

When he was on field this season he showed he’s still by far the best finisher in our team. I bet if we let him go he will really hurt us next year.
Agreed Josh was sidelined for 8 weeks and heavily strapped if Josh was in full flight I think he would’ve scored he is the best finisher in the game period
 

maroondog72

Kennel Immortal
Gilded
Joined
Apr 6, 2017
Messages
18,972
Reaction score
34,805
Yeah we only want players that think, train and play footy 24/7. They must be robots, only worrying about entertaining us and nothing else!
You’ve had some pretty shit takes, but that one wins the cigar, lol. What would you expect a player to be focused on the week before a finals game? You are just making yourself look like a dick head now.
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
It’s actually almost two thirds who believe that according to the poll, but try telling that to the vocal minority who want to browbeat others for having a different opinion.

I do think Gus is trying to shove him out the door though, mate. If he wasn’t, he wouldn’t be allowing his press lackey to write negative articles questioning Fox’s commitment.
Well Foxx committed he came out and said it let’s see what happens either way in my opinion I wouldn’t get rid of him GUS has more money to spend why get rid of the best finishers in the game..

Trindall case far worse illicit drugs over the limit no license and what he probably lied too but Cronulla didn’t get rid of him look at Trindall now he is a machine!!!
Mitchell loose cannon
Latrell is just dumb and has blind rage shame cause he was never like that and knocks out his own kind with his knees aka Josh and meant to be a mentor for the indigenous community. Mitchell is no GREG Inglis and never will be Bennett you really think he can control that menace Latrell does what he wants. What he did to Shawn Johnson got up and just elbowed him in the jaw god knows how he didn’t he sent off.

Wait hold
Up I have the answer Andrew abdo will speak to him lol what a joke
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
It’s actually almost two thirds who believe that according to the poll, but try telling that to the vocal minority who want to browbeat others for having a different opinion.

I do think Gus is trying to shove him out the door though, mate. If he wasn’t, he wouldn’t be allowing his press lackey to write negative articles questioning Fox’s commitment.
We all know and love the Foxx he has done it I guarantee if they tested the team 50% would’ve been on it they were all at a hotel
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
Mad Monday they all fucking use cocaine every team Josh just did it at the wrong time who cares.. we didnt miss him that game.
We missed MANN AS soon as he got injured but Mann the destroyer is Back the machine can take down anyone
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
Vote is there already we don’t wanna loose him and I think either does the board he would’ve been picked up already by another club GUS is smart with his words it’s like he is steering people away from Josh so he stays. Well that’s what I think anyway
 

Utility

Kennel Immortal
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
24,572
Reaction score
23,391
Well Foxx committed he came out and said it let’s see what happens either way in my opinion I wouldn’t get rid of him GUS has more money to spend why get rid of the best finishers in the game..

Trindall case far worse illicit drugs over the limit no license and what he probably lied too but Cronulla didn’t get rid of him look at Trindall now he is a machine!!!
Mitchell loose cannon
Latrell is just dumb and has blind rage shame cause he was never like that and knocks out his own kind with his knees aka Josh and meant to be a mentor for the indigenous community. Mitchell is no GREG Inglis and never will be Bennett you really think he can control that menace Latrell does what he wants. What he did to Shawn Johnson got up and just elbowed him in the jaw god knows how he didn’t he sent off.

Wait hold
Up I have the answer Andrew abdo will speak to him lol what a joke
The only reason this has been made into such a big deal is Gus was made to look silly, imo,
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
The only reason this has been made into such a big deal is Gus was made to look silly, imo,
Yes I agree he just had to make a statement so he doesn’t like that but either way do we know every detail no it’s only between those 4 walls and the board

the information we know is cocaine was in his system and he made a white lie
 

Utility

Kennel Immortal
Joined
May 25, 2011
Messages
24,572
Reaction score
23,391
Just look at the game against manly if we had fox we would’ve won Skelton bombed a try which fox would’ve nailed and Skelton let in a try fox would’ve went for the interception.
We would have won the game if he’d played, do the logical solution is to get rid of him and not have him around to potentially win games on the future? Don’t really get the logic. And I don’t blame him for the loss either. We were do dominant in that game and had plenty of chances to win it. If Reed makes done better decisions on the field we win it. If Tracey makes a good defensive decision and stops that final Manly try we win it… and the list goes on.
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
We would have won the game if he’d played, do the logical solution is to get rid of him and not have him around to potentially win games on the future? Don’t really get the logic. And I don’t blame him for the loss either. We were do dominant in that game and had plenty of chances to win it. If Reed makes done better decisions on the field we win it. If Tracey makes a good defensive decision and stops that final Manly try we win it… and the list goes on.
Bench salmon and have Mann on we would’ve taken down Koula at lock salmon has no speed for a fish lol
 

Johnnny2233

Kennel Enthusiast
Joined
Jul 23, 2023
Messages
3,079
Reaction score
2,343
We would have won the game if he’d played, do the logical solution is to get rid of him and not have him around to potentially win games on the future? Don’t really get the logic. And I don’t blame him for the loss either. We were do dominant in that game and had plenty of chances to win it. If Reed makes done better decisions on the field we win it. If Tracey makes a good defensive decision and stops that final Manly try we win it… and the list goes on.
Yeah Reed kinda fucked us too that seven tackle set and stupid penalty there baiting him he use to be the baiter and reed feel into there bait.

Mann knows how to set up plays step move salmon just I don’t know Ciro loves him maybe it’s that Penrith thing. Salmon needs to learn how to play like MANN
 

L.B

Kennel Established
Joined
Mar 23, 2024
Messages
763
Reaction score
1,165
Why are you personally attacking @axeman23 for sharing his opinion? He didn’t attack you, just stated his view and you go on a tyrade ffs.

So you are happy for JAC to be gone, because he didn’t wear a finger brace, so now requires surgery and he wants to play in the Koori Knockout, one of, if not the most important carnivals for black fellas? That’s it aye, that’s enough to push it over the edge? Lol ok.
Okay so maybe you need to have a read back at what he actually said before jumping down my throat and having your 2 cents worth! They guy had a go at me and had to thrown in “my oestrogen levels because I commented that JAC is only thinking of himself by not caring for himself! I’m allowed to have an opinion and clearly he didn’t like it, hence you throw insults at me I’m gonna throw them back. Don’t dish it if you can’t take it. It’s as simple as that
 

axeman23

Kennel Established
Joined
Jul 20, 2017
Messages
825
Reaction score
1,240
Okay so maybe you need to have a read back at what he actually said before jumping down my throat and having your 2 cents worth! They guy had a go at me and had to thrown in “my oestrogen levels because I commented that JAC is only thinking of himself by not caring for himself! I’m allowed to have an opinion and clearly he didn’t like it, hence you throw insults at me I’m gonna throw them back. Don’t dish it if you can’t take it. It’s as simple as that
A few things: Firstly, I wasn't particularly offended by your reply to me, just so we're clear. Secondly, it was more a reply to you, and the article you replied to, AND (as I've said) a section of the Kennel who have seemed to have had the knives out for JAC for a while. Thirdly, I just looked at your profile pic: are you a female? If so, I apologize, that didn't even register with me one iota. I guess i have a bad habit of ASSUMING posters on sports forum are guys. Which while usually true, has no bearing on the quality (real or percieved) of your posts. The "oestrogen" comment was an off-the-cuff remark about my thoughts of a lot of fans in general: They don't appreciate what they have, until it turns around and bites them on the arse, then they're like: "OMG, HOW did this HAPPEN???" So again, my comment was not aimed at you personally, or intentionally sexist, so if you took it as such and were offended, I apologize...
 

Bulldogsteve

Kennel Legend
Premium Member
SC H2H Champion
SC Top Scorer
Joined
Jun 29, 2020
Messages
8,370
Reaction score
15,289
Vote is there already we don’t wanna loose him and I think either does the board he would’ve been picked up already by another club GUS is smart with his words it’s like he is steering people away from Josh so he stays. Well that’s what I think anyway
if someone wanted fox they would have already contacted the club
 

CBDog

In the Zone
Joined
Apr 10, 2011
Messages
1,731
Reaction score
814
If his sole focus was football and rehab etc it might be worth rolling the dice with him for another few seasons but it’s pretty obvious that’s not what he’s about, Bellyache knows when to cut them loose.
I remember the famous Sydney racehorse trainer Tommy Smith.
If he cut a horse loose it might end up winning a race out the back of Broken Hill.
Obvious Bellyache new things that outsiders to Melbourne did not.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top