Regarding Josh Addo Carr

[Bad Billy]

I felt dirty.

You loved it.

 

[maroondog72]

You know, I could understand why people would want him to stay if he were a spine player, or game changer but ...

We keep him despite what he's done then we may as well keep anyone in the future, right?

Where do you draw the line as he's not going to improve. Not with us anyway

Add to that he is becoming more injury prone every year and offers us fucking zero coming out of our own end, and people are carrying on like we are losing To'o FFS.

 

[Kaz]

You loved it.

I could actually post things, without the worry of being 'attacked'

I actually miss Gene.

 

[EXPLORER]

Add to that he is becoming more injury prone every year and offers us fucking zero coming out of our own end, and people are carrying on like we are losing To'o FFS.

I tend to agree with the point you are making here.

The main thing that sets Addo Carr apart from other players is speed.
He is almost 30 and will gradually lose that speed.

It's all down hill from here for him as a player.

I think we should all repect what he has done for our club,
He came here when no one else would, and I believe he did attract players to come also.

But I think it's time to part ways with him.
Wish him all the best, and move on.

 

[maroondog72]

I tend to agree with the point you are making here.

The main thing that sets Addo Carr apart from other players is speed.
He is almost 30 and will gradually lose that speed.

It's all down hill from here for him as a player.

I think we should all repect what he has done for our club,
He came here when no one else would, and I believe he did attract players to come also.

But I think it's time to part ways with him.
Wish him all the best, and move on.

If his sole focus was football and rehab etc it might be worth rolling the dice with him for another few seasons but it’s pretty obvious that’s not what he’s about, Bellyache knows when to cut them loose.

 

[Bad Billy]

I could actually post things, without the worry of being 'attacked'

I actually miss Gene.

Was a different time back then.
people could take a joke without getting their feelings hurt.
you can’t even dislike a post anymore?
This generation of buttercups will eventually reap what they have sewn.

 

[Dyldog]

Why the hell, didn't the DH, keep the injured finger in a brace.

It’s unprofessional selfish behaviour.

 

[Kaz]

Was a different time back then.
people could take a joke without getting their feelings hurt.
you can’t even dislike a post anymore?
This generation of buttercups will eventually reap what they have sewn.

You could argue with people & next post have a laugh. (the memories)

I can dislike a post, by posting that it was shit. lol

 

[axeman23]

Nah. I get what you're saying but nah.

He's class like but he isn't a game changer. He's a winger. If we had a competent winger like Wilson in that game we would've won.

JAC is a luxury that we don't need anymore. If he stays I'll back him like I do every other player, apart from when those 4 ***** went to Parra, but people are trying to make out we can't win without him.

Bullocks to that. We've evolved to the point he isn't anywhere near a necessity. Good on us

Yeah, that's fair enough. I just meant he's absolutely capable of changing A game, with 1 moment. But the ball still has to get out to him/out his WAY, even, so I'd certainly agree he's not a game-changer in the class of a Cleary, Jahrome, Munster, DCE, even a Teddy/Turbo. I'd just much rather him on our team than an opposition team for that 1 moment that might be a difference between going out in the semies, and a Premiership. Is he likely to go up another gear at his age? Most likely not. It just doesn't sit right with me the way some people here are so quick to take players out behind the proverbial shed, then bang on about how the players owe the club, Gus, and even those same fans, undivided, fanatical loyalty.

 

[TwinTurbo]

Yeah, that's fair enough. I just meant he's absolutely capable of changing A game, with 1 moment. But the ball still has to get out to him/out his WAY, even, so I'd certainly agree he's not a game-changer in the class of a Cleary, Jahrome, Munster, DCE, even a Teddy/Turbo. I'd just much rather him on our team than an opposition team for that 1 moment that might be a difference between going out in the semies, and a Premiership. Is he likely to go up another gear at his age? Most likely not. It just doesn't sit right with me the way some people here are so quick to take players out behind the proverbial shed, then bang on about how the players owe the club, Gus, and even those same fans, undivided, fanatical loyalty.

"Cleary, Jahrome, Munster, DCE, even a Teddy/Turbo" are all spine players, JAC is a winger and expecting him to the same influence on a game as a spine players is ridiculous.


Team First

 

[Kempsey Dog]

Well that’s an interesting pole result, it would seem that the 36% that vote “yes“ are simply a noisy minority. They post often and loud so it seems like they are a majority, but the fact is they aren’t. The silent, or more accurately quieter, majority are not so easily influenced by those who think by posting the same shit multiple times that they will convince them, seems not.


Team First

Or maybe they are Fox fanboys I dunno

 

[axeman23]

"Cleary, Jahrome, Munster, DCE, even a Teddy/Turbo" are all spine players, JAC is a winger and expecting him to the same influence on a game as a spine players is ridiculous.


Team First

That is pretty much what I said, "the ball still needs to get out to him", as opposed to those spine players who get their hands on the ball much easier...

 

[TwinTurbo]

That is pretty much what I said, "the ball still needs to get out to him", as opposed to those spine players who get their hands on the ball much easier...

I was agreeing with you.


Team First

 

[Johnnny2233]

I tend to agree with the point you are making here.

The main thing that sets Addo Carr apart from other players is speed.
He is almost 30 and will gradually lose that speed.

It's all down hill from here for him as a player.

I think we should all repect what he has done for our club,
He came here when no one else would, and I believe he did attract players to come also.

But I think it's time to part ways with him.
Wish him all the best, and move on.

I think GUS just silenced the media besides hearing that stupid swap which is fake GUS had to shut down the media quick smart

 

[Johnnny2233]

Yeah, that's fair enough. I just meant he's absolutely capable of changing A game, with 1 moment. But the ball still has to get out to him/out his WAY, even, so I'd certainly agree he's not a game-changer in the class of a Cleary, Jahrome, Munster, DCE, even a Teddy/Turbo. I'd just much rather him on our team than an opposition team for that 1 moment that might be a difference between going out in the semies, and a Premiership. Is he likely to go up another gear at his age? Most likely not. It just doesn't sit right with me the way some people here are so quick to take players out behind the proverbial shed, then bang on about how the players owe the club, Gus, and even those same fans, undivided, fanatical loyalty.

He does change games no one can disagree with that I think he has 1 year left and then that’s it whether he chooses to leave that was the response your more than welcome to explore other options. Put the dots together if the Foxx was to get sacked it would’ve been done already I don’t know but we still got a long way in knowing what is happening anyway

 

[Johnnny2233]

He does change games no one can disagree with that I think he has 1 year left and then that’s it whether he chooses to leave that was the response your more than welcome to explore other options. Put the dots together if the Foxx was to get sacked it would’ve been done already I don’t know but we still got a long way in knowing what is happening anyway

He says he won’t wear another NRL jersey well we will see anyways I signed out of the kennel cause this thread got too much.

I say shut the thread down until we know in the next couple months

 

[Johnnny2233]

You could argue with people & next post have a laugh. (the memories)

I can dislike a post, by posting that it was shit. lol

I wouldn’t take any broncos players there in shambles such a fake interview I respect Kevin Walters. He has been through a lot. But the broncos are just making up shit making him an ambassador yeah there are 100 ambassadors.

His son is the most annoying hooker in the game wanna talk about pests he is a pest. As as much Tyrone peachy can one of the boys just knock him out if they see him out west he is a gronk calling out reed.

make over 1000 tackes then talk Tyrone little snail

 

[Grunthos]

I tend to agree with the point you are making here.

The main thing that sets Addo Carr apart from other players is speed.
He is almost 30 and will gradually lose that speed.

It's all down hill from here for him as a player.

I think we should all repect what he has done for our club,
He came here when no one else would, and I believe he did attract players to come also.

But I think it's time to part ways with him.
Wish him all the best, and move on.

When the Hammer ran him down it was the beginning of the end.

 

[Utility]

Or maybe they are Fox fanboys I dunno

61.7 percent of the forum are Fox fan boys? Keep telling yourself that if it helps you sleep at night.

Some of us just appreciate what he has done for the club and think he deserves more respect than some are showing him. Another Danny Wiedler PR piece isn’t going to change that.

 

[Tassie Devil]

61.7 percent of the forum are Fox fan boys? Keep telling yourself that if it helps you sleep at night.

Some of us just appreciate what he has done for the club and think he deserves more respect than some are showing him. Another Danny Wiedker PR piece isn’t going to change that.

Wait. I'm being disrespectful by saying I understand why the club would let him know? And perhaps it's the best choice all-round?