Moses Or Moses

[Novdoggie]

If you had the choice who would you take, Moses Mbye or Mitchell Moses?

Responses will be interesting. Let's see who comes out on top tonight.

 

[Freakzilla]

Mitchell Moses has a way better kicking game and sets up way more tries.

 

[ouwet]

Tough decision!

It'll be as tough as going into a brothel and being left to choose from the two no one else wanted...

I'd walk out and never look back...

Neither Moses's for me

 

[Mr Invisible]

Hmmm that's a choice between:
Shitloads of missed tackles but can kick; and
Solid defence but does nothing.

Tough call.

 

[Bakes]

It's a tough decision because Mbye is an athlete being forced to play in a position that doesn't suit him. If Mbye had been hooker, centre or maybe even fullback he may have killed it. We haven't seen his potential thanks to Des but we can see he is not a 7

 

[M4cca]

Probably mitch. Although mbye has better defence, its easier for mitch to gain a bit more size and tackle better than it is to teach someone how to ball play

 

[FaceBreaker]

Mitchell Moses, no question.

 

[Flanagun]

Can we have the Moses from the Old Testament instead? I think he'd get Des' gameplan.....was probably around when it was invented.

 

[BMOC]

Get out of here. Moses Mbye is one of the best players in the dogs side. He is just not playing in the right position. His pass is better than mitch. His speed is better than mitch. His size is better than mitch. His defence and tackles are better than mitch. His athleticism is better than mitch...He is way better than Mitch!!

 

[Izzy Forreal]

It's a tough decision because Mbye is an athlete being forced to play in a position that doesn't suit him. If Mbye had been hooker, centre or maybe even fullback he may have killed it. We haven't seen his potential thanks to Des but we can see he is not a 7

Yeah, great work Des. With your own inimitable ability you've proved beyond doubt what Moses Mbye isn't.

Is there any chance that you might give us a hint as to what he is?

 

[finchie]

North qld were offered mbye or temaire Martin
Guess who they went with
The answer speaks for itself and even Thurston doesn't rate him

 

[Freakzilla]

North qld were offered mbye or temaire Martin
Guess who they went with
The answer speaks for itself and even Thurston doesn't rate him

To be fair their salaries was also a big factor. Moses gets paid more than double.

 

[finchie]

To be fair their salaries was also a big factor. Moses gets paid more than double.

We were going to be pay half
Temaire is on 300k plus
It wasn't that big of a difference

 

[bcmf]

Let's meld them and form a guy who can defend and tackle but can also set stuff up.

We'll call him Thurston or Joey.

 

[Brizdog]

Mitchell Moses has a better coach so i'll go with him

 

[Freakzilla]

We were going to be pay half
Temaire is on 300k plus
It wasn't that big of a difference

Mbye is on 800k. Can't see us paying more than 200k

 

[finchie]

Mbye is on 800k. Can't see us paying more than 200k

He's not on 800
But anyways I get you point
But they still went with Martin regardless
If jt wanted mbye at nqld he'd be there by now

 

[Serpent]

In a perfect world neither.

 

[BondiBulldog]

Anyone who creates a post like this should almost be banned. Zero lack of football knowledge to even compare.
Mitchell Moses is a young and talented half. Not established but a half.
Moses Mbye is not a half and I haven't seen him play enough hooker or 'fullback' to say he is even a first grader.
Moses Mbye would be the WORSE professional paid League player. This includes CRL, QLD cup etc.