News Match Review / Judiciary round 5 charges

[chisdog]

 

[chisdog]

This "contrary conduct" charge tells you nothing. I am guessing that Asofa-Solomona has been fined for the punch on Ogden whilst Melbourne players held him down & had him pinned but what was Ofahiki fined for? He shoved Munster after Munster tocked him on the head. He didn't throw any punches. Munster should have been binned for starting the whole thing. I hope Bellamy had a word to him about getting that crap out of his game.

I seem to remember a game last year when an opponent made a mistake which led us to one of our few tries for the year, one of our players could have rubbed his nose in the mistake, but instead picked him up & was a good sport about it. I think it was Georgallis who made special mention of the good sportsmanship there.

 

[Blue&whiteAxe]

Says misconduct carried out on Papenhuyzen? Wtf

 

[_G-Dog_]

After seeing all the footage this week of what went on in the days of Tommy Raudonikis .. this was a nothing incident..

 

[Scoooby]

After seeing all the footage this week of what went on in the days of Tommy Raudonikis .. this was a nothing incident..

Absolutely, but you know how it is.!! Crap.

 

[wendog33]

They deem the NAS punch a fine, the same as Ofa's ?

Crazy bias.

 

[Battybulldog]

Ogden pulled Papenhuyzens hair 50m upfield, which started a little scuffle. Storm scored the same set, which is why Munster gave Ofa the treatment after the try. Ogdens been cited for the hair pull, NAS for the punch.

 

[wendog33]

Ogden pulled Papenhuyzens hair 50m upfield, which started a little scuffle. Storm scored the same set, which is why Munster gave Ofa the treatment after the try. Ogdens been cited for the hair pull, NAS for the punch.

Ok ...but a punch is the same fine as a hair pull? Aren't punches completely outlawed?

 

[BULLDVGS]

Ok ...but a punch is the same fine as a hair pull? Aren't punches completely outlawed?

Hair pull is a complete bitch move and Ofa should be suspended if it was deliberate.

 

[Battybulldog]

 

[wendog33]

Hair pull is a complete bitch move and Ofa should be suspended if it was deliberate.

True but not defending hair pulls.

Is it same scale fine as a punch, which we were told is completely banned and the worst offence in same category as gouging and biting?

Seems lop sided charge to me under the rules.

 

[Battybulldog]

 

[wendog33]

View attachment 23022

No hair in his hand!

 

[BELMORE]

True but not defending hair pulls.

Is it same scale fine as a punch, which we were told is completely banned and the worst offence in same category as gouging and biting?

Seems lop sided charge to me under the rules.

Who told you that....

 

[Battybulldog]

10 in the bin and a $1500 fine is justified for both I think

 

[wendog33]

Pics/vid of NAS' punch of the guy on the ground please .

 

[wendog33]

Who told you that....

A man with a dog.

 

[BULLDVGS]

True but not defending hair pulls.

Is it same scale fine as a punch, which we were told is completely banned and the worst offence in same category as gouging and biting?

Seems lop sided charge to me under the rules.

Its hard to say tbh. Id say hair pull (if deliberate) and dogshot punch are on the same plane on the footy field.

 

[Battybulldog]

Gyazo Screen Video

gyazo.com

Think Nelsons charge might be for the knee to the head.. I didn't see this live.

 

[wendog33]

Its hard to say tbh. Id say hair pull (if deliberate) and dogshot punch are on the same plane on the footy field.

Yes I agree but I'd rather a hair pull than a punch on the ground not expecting it.