Hed begun playing half assed at club level as soon as he became an origin regular. It always made me sad seeing him go into beast mode playing origin. Then return to club football and play like he didn't want to get his jersey dirty.
He was still a good workhorse then and our pack had gotten to the point where it was very underwhelming and we needed the aggressive prop that he was in origin to show himself. But he was never going to do that again for us. We needed him to grow into an on field leader and inspire the team. He'd obviously heard about Pearce trying to root dogs and wanted to get in on that action as a firmer dog.
Since he left he shit on the club verbally right after leaving. It was widely reported that he was dumped from origin because he was a massively negative influence around camp. Complained like a bitch because he was relegated to an interchange prop based on the articles I read at the time. And with our team right now seeming like it's going well via the incredible attitude, I'd hate to see us lose that attitude because we recruited someone who was his own biggest fan.
So if it was a voting thing, I would vote that we didn't ever bring him back to the club. But we needn't bother talking about this since he's supposed to be dragon bound anyway.