Inu/Fa'aoso supensions - whats the deal?

[MatstaDogg]

Inu cops 5 weeks for early guilty plea for his spear tackle, then gets an extra week with the rule change.

Now today Fa'aoso takes an early guilty plea for not one but two spear tackles in the one game, with carry over points and gets only 8weeks?

My question is where is the justice in the the system? Why is Inu being punished more? Are we just getting the rough end of the stick as usual?

 

[Ironhide07]

NRL Judiciary system is a joke

 

[Vlasnik]

Inu cops 5 weeks for early guilty plea for his spear tackle, then gets an extra week with the rule change.

Now today Fa'aoso takes an early guilty plea for not one but two spear tackles in the one game, with carry over points and gets only 8weeks?

My question is where is the justice in the the system? Why is Inu being punished more? Are we just getting the rough end of the stick as usual?

Mate you answered your own question with a question.

 

[The DoggFather]

NRL Judiciary system is a joke

NRL as a whole is a joke

 

[Raysie]

Inu plays for the Bulldogs, that's why.

 

[bulldogs_fan_69]

lol

 

[Pom_81]

I hate to break ranks on here, but I have no objection to this.

Inu's was graded at Grade 4. Fa'aoso's were Grade 2 and Grade 3. That seems reasonable to me - both were not as bad as Inu's in isolation of each other, but two obviously adds up.

 

[Eagle eye]

I hate to break ranks on here, but I have no objection to this.

Inu's was graded at Grade 4. Fa'aoso's were Grade 2 and Grade 3. That seems reasonable to me - both were not as bad as Inu's in isolation of each other, but two obviously adds up.

I think you're right Pom. Neither of Fa'oso's were as bad as Inu's but collectively, he ended up with a longer holiday.

 

[billybob]

I hate to break ranks on here, but I have no objection to this.

Inu's was graded at Grade 4. Fa'aoso's were Grade 2 and Grade 3. That seems reasonable to me - both were not as bad as Inu's in isolation of each other, but two obviously adds up.

Taking off my biased bulldog goggles i gotta say i agree, while i don't think inu is a dirty player at all his spear tackle certainly looked worse.

 

[Bad Billy]

Inu's tackle was much worse. Fa'oso didn't drive ingles in either of his tackles.
I'd like nothing more than seeing a many player suffer, but in this case the judiciary got it right. (Although it was still fun to see toovey snap)

 

[hotdiggitydogs]

Although, Fa'oso did make two tackles which causes Ingles to end of his head (he should have been sent off after the second, at least for ten), they were no where as bad as Inu's. Fa'oso was one motion pick up and drop, Inu tried once to lift, failed then did it again and succeeded, and SHOULD have been sent off.
Both Judiciary penalties were fair.

 

[Snowmann]

Its fair, Inu looked like he was using Inglis as a shovel from some angles..

 

[pupii]

Stop with the victim mentality. He copped 8 weeks for two tackles that were no where near as bad as Inu`s.

 

[Izzy Forreal]

I think the eight week suspension is far too lenient. Forget about the gradings, either one of Fa'aoso's tackles could have caused spinal damage.

What happened is that Fa'aoso spear tackled Inglis and got put on report. Then being either an absolute dope or a psychopath he repeats the dose and gets put on report again. Two spear tackles in one game. Inu's might have looked worse but Fa'aoso's repeat dose showed he had intent to do damage to Inglis, not just shake him up.

 

[Stoofy]

I think the eight week suspension is far too lenient. Forget about the gradings, either one of Fa'aoso's tackles could have caused spinal damage.

What happened is that Fa'aoso spear tackled Inglis and got put on report. Then being either an absolute dope or a psychopath he repeats the dose and gets put on report again. Two spear tackles in one game. Inu's might have looked worse but Fa'aoso's repeat dose showed he had intent to do damage to Inglis, not just shake him up.

Agree 100%. The second tackle was either poor technique or premeditated. Not good!

 

[Papa Emeritus]

I hate to break ranks on here, but I have no objection to this.

Inu's was graded at Grade 4. Fa'aoso's were Grade 2 and Grade 3. That seems reasonable to me - both were not as bad as Inu's in isolation of each other, but two obviously adds up.

The voice of reason.

Inu's was worse guys, if you can't see that then I do not know what to say.

 

[chris_e_fresh]

he should of been given 8 weeks ofr the tackles but an extra 4 because he is a c**t

 

[Pom_81]

he should of been given 8 weeks ofr the tackles but an extra 4 because he is a c**t

If the judiciary took that into account, Matai would be getting a life ban.

 

[Big_Dawg]

Greg inglis is a jumper it so obvious

 

[MrDogzOfWar]

NRL Judiciary system is a joke

Of Course It's a JOKE... Just Because he plays for the Bulldogs... The NRL has always been AGAINST US...