In your opinion who is the most underrated Bulldogs player ever?

[Moey]

Injuries?

Wasn't injuries. I didnt think he was the lock we needed and im pretty sure we won comp after he left.

He left end of 2003 and we won 2004.

 

[Dogmonster]

Poor Max Mannix still probably get's ribbed by his mates for that mistake, as soon as I read his name first thing I remembered was that dive to end an amazing break by our doggies, at least we still won.

Taking the piss yeah, after reading through the names im seeing, Craig Polla Mounter deserves a massive mention, and he also bought my parents first house i lived in till i was 6 year old at Condell Park. He built another house up the back of the big block and had his parents there also. Polly was class.

 

[Phalangist]

Luke Patten - hands down.

Best player ever, who never played rep footy.

Joel Romelo was also under rated, I dont know where he is now.

no Rod Silva and Craig polla mounter were better then Luke patten.

 

[Mr Shhh]

Tim Pickup
Phil Charlton
Mighty Mitch Newton
John Coveney
Matt Ryan
Lee Pompret
Sandra Campbell
Tas Bateri
Pat English

 

[Dogmonster]

Tim Pickup
Phil Charlton
Mighty Mitch Newton
John Coveney
Matt Ryan
Lee Pompret
Sandra Campbell
Tas Bateri
Pat English

Lol is that Sandy Campbell

 

[Marki]

Hutch was the worst golfer I have ever seen.
Played in an ambrose with him and Braith in Coffs Harbour (Bonville) in 2004.
The day before the shit hit the fan.
Hutch had about 25 air swing tee shots in the 18 holes.

Lucky he could golf coz he couldn't play footy for shit!

 

[Mr Shhh]

Lol is that Sandy Campbell

Yeah, just trying for some humour.

 

[Dogmonster]

Yeah, just trying for some humour.

Yeah i know, he was more worried about how he looked than how he played.

 

[Trinfly]

Max Mannix

Poor old Max I was at the game when he dropped that ball over line never seen so many kids go from cheering to jeering in a flat second lol

 

[Trinfly]

Pollamounter and Feeney

 

[transom]

I don't think this player would be the most under rated. But I think Braidon Burns is a much better player than given credit for. And also I think he would make a good fullback.

 

[Indiandog]

no Rod Silva and Craig polla mounter were better then Luke patten.

maybe, but i didnt see them play

 

[hayes]

Luke Patten - hands down.

Best player ever, who never played rep footy.

Joel Romelo was also under rated, I dont know where he is now.

Romelo got lock up in Darwin

 

[maroondog72]

Lachlan Lewis, no one will ever be able to replicate the cut out pass that would break some poor bastards nose in the third row of the Grandstand
















Hethrington by a mile.

 

[Cantabrian35]

So many great underrated players over the years... Hage, Coveney, Joe Thomas, Tony Currie (was just about the best player in the world when we won in 1988), Gillies, Grimaldi, Hagan (played three grand finals in three different positions), Reardon, Grimaldi. But for me, it was Peter Kelly. He was so tough he made JWH look like Barbie and was the best player on the field in the 1984 and 85 grand finals. Still can't believe he didn't play a test match.

 

[Rodzilla]

Kimmorley also underrated at the dogs and also career underrated

 

[hackenbush]

Gillies, Reardon & Stan Cutler

 

[Bazildog]

Lachlan Lewis, no one will ever be able to replicate the cut out pass that would break some poor bastards nose in the third row of the Grandstand
















Hethrington by a mile.

I don’t think Hetho was underrated though..? Was a fuckin gun and typified what a Bulldog is.

Relf, Reardon, Polly, Casilles, Matua, Ward, Gary Hughes, Silva and even Greg Eastwood I thought were underrated for the players they were..

 

[Bazildog]

So many great underrated players over the years... Hage, Coveney, Joe Thomas, Tony Currie (was just about the best player in the world when we won in 1988), Gillies, Grimaldi, Hagan (played three grand finals in three different positions), Reardon, Grimaldi. But for me, it was Peter Kelly. He was so tough he made JWH look like Barbie and was the best player on the field in the 1984 and 85 grand finals. Still can't believe he didn't play a test match.

Good post but no-one under rated Peter Kelly. Top 5 Bulldog prop ever.

 

[Cantabrian35]

Gillies, Reardon & Stan Cutler

I forgot Stan, great player and clubman.