100% it was over hyped. The club did plenty of PR shit during pre season and the trials that it was going to be a bumper season. Yet somehow Gould's supporters are spinning that he was very clear about it being a total write off before the season even kicked off.
He was very overly optimistic in his media, he's only turned full negative since the Knights flogging
Neither of those positions are true.
Yes the club did PR - they have to.
The Kennel videos were good gear and what fans were calling out for - more content from the club.
That said I wouldn’t have re-signed Reynolds nor trumpeted his ‘homecoming’.
If you attended the AGM and/or season launch as I did, you’d know Gould spoke cautiously of the season but he neither talked things up nor described it as a ‘total write off’. What he DID say was Ciraldo wanted ‘in the fight’ when Gus told him he could stay another year and win another comp at Penrith. He actually said the Dogs still had ‘a trip down the mines’ before we could compete with most of the other teams.
I don’t think Ciraldo is the problem.
Cleary did nothing at the Tigers, went back to Penrith and came out smelling roses. Madge went from a title at Souths to the cellar at the Tigers.
Those who don’t want to buy in, no worries show them the door and see who’s willing to pay them big coin to do nothing post football.