HALFBACK: Roberts v Sherwin

[Tha DoggFather]

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmm, because he is our future halfback, like it or not, so I dont know why we should waste him AGAIN in PL and risk losing him just to keep an emotional dud of a halfback happy!

 

[Tha DoggFather]

BTW its 19 to 8 now LOL

But unlike you, I respect what people think, I dont sit here and accuse them of being kids and not knowing anything about our team

 

[Mickdog]

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmm, because he is our future halfback, like it or not, so I dont know why we should waste him AGAIN in PL and risk losing him just to keep an emotional dud of a halfback happy!

So your point is because he is the future? Brad Murray is the future. More potential then Roberts and Holdsworth combined.

Roberts may be our future halfback when Sherwin is dropped or leaves next year or the year after but why not play him at hooker for now? I personally see him as a much better option on the bench at this time. I would have him in the 17 but not at the expense of Shifty.

Emeotional dud or not he is more experienced and almost got us to the GF.

 

[Keefy]

Roberts may be our future halfback when Serwin is dropped or leaves next year or the year after but why not play him at hooker .

Who the F*#k is Serwin

 

[Mickdog]

BTW its 19 to 8 now LOL

But unlike you, I respect what people think, I dont sit here and accuse them of being kids and not knowing anything about our team

You called me an imbecile directly attacking me. But you complain that I call you what you are? I'm sorry if I offended anybody by my comments. Happy now. I think I deserve an apology as well.

20 to 8 now. Oh and if you respect what people think why do you attack them personaly when having a diffeeeing opinion to your own?

 

[Tha DoggFather]

You still crying about it? I REACTED to your bullsh!t comments buddy, didnt instigate anything.

So get the hell over it will you.

 

[Mickdog]

You still crying about it? I REACTED to your bullsh!t comments buddy, didnt instigate anything.

So get the hell over it will you.

Oh I have no problem with it at all. Call me wqhatever you want. They always say that people who can't debate prefer to attack a person.

You still haven't told me why you think Roberts is better then Sherwin?

 

[Tha DoggFather]

They always say that people who can't debate prefer to attack a person.

You still haven't told me why you think Roberts is better then Sherwin?

LOL, your the one that said we dont know anything about our team and so on.

Simply because our current halfback has seen better days and our PL halfback is already a REP player and already looks to be better than Sherwin would ever be.

 

[Bulldogs50]

So your point is because he is the future? Brad Murray is the future. More potential then Roberts and Holdsworth combined.

Roberts may be our future halfback when Sherwin is dropped or leaves next year or the year after but why not play him at hooker for now? I personally see him as a much better option on the bench at this time. I would have him in the 17 but not at the expense of Shifty.

Emeotional dud or not he is more experienced and almost got us to the GF.

i actually couldnt agree more.. in league these days you need to get the top 17 players in the team. Players are more versatile than they used to be! get roberts in at hooker off the bench.

 

[Bulldogs50]

LOL, your the one that said we dont know anything about our team and so on.

Simply because our current halfback has seen better days and our PL halfback is already a REP player and already looks to be better than Sherwin would ever be.

LMAO a Rep player..

 

[Tha DoggFather]

Prove me wrong mate

 

[Dawgfather]

Roberts is only a rep player coz NZ have **** all in the way of halfbacks

 

[Tha DoggFather]

Correct me if im wrong but this thread says that Roberts is a rep player

http://www.thekennel.com.au/forum/showthread.php?t=24741

What has shifty done? He played CvC once back 2-3 years ago.

 

[Tha DoggFather]

Roberts is only a rep player coz NZ have **** all in the way of halfbacks

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmm, he played 5/8th ginger

 

[Horse]

Correct me if im wrong but this thread says that Roberts is a rep player

http://www.thekennel.com.au/forum/showthread.php?t=24741

What has shifty done? He played CvC once back 2-3 years ago.

not only that match but he played for NZ against GB earlier in the year overseas.

 

[fatal1]

Sherwin for ONE more year... If he dosnt fire this year, we all should consider lobbying The board

agreed but as i have said before, roberts must be in the 17 somewhere in 2007

 

[Tha DoggFather]

Nah thats not good enough b13, only CvC is rep :rolleyes:

 

[Bulldogs50]

city verse country is rep.. much harder to make then the side roberts made

 

[Tha DoggFather]

Yeah, much much harder! :rolleyes:

Well done shifty!

 

[Bulldogs50]

and its an invitational.. its not an official rep! you think the prime ministers game with australia and whoever it was, was an official rep game? NO!! none of those players gained a cap..

exactly the same as roberts.

Ben Roberts NZ Caps: 0