CBDog
In the Zone
- Joined
- Apr 10, 2011
- Messages
- 941
- Reaction score
- 42
Re question concerning Barba and Idris. Barba would be my pick. this is his first year in FG in the full back position. His confidence is growing every game and couple that withWe were talking before, and I mentioned Barba. I'm not 100% sure but I'm certain he's off contract next season and while we didn't want Idris gone, the amount of money we were offering him could have been deadly in terms of keeping/losing Barba.
I know no one has mentioned Barba but we need to put things into perspective here. If you had a choice between keeping a centre with potential or a fullback with massive potential, which one are you going to keep? Which position is more important? Which position is vital in actually winning a grand final?
What if we did re-sign Idris at that ridiculous 380K a season and we lost Barba the very next season? Who's to blame for that?
Like I said before, we, Anna and I, didn't want Idris gone at all costs but to throw that kind of money at a centre, especially when your fullback is off contract next season is just plain stupid and would have undone pretty much all of the good work, in terms of recruitment and retention, Todd Greenberg has done for us. He was willing to pay overs (assuming the 380K was correct) but he made the smart decision in not paying anywhere near the brain dead price Titans did.
People need to remember that and understand the team's priorities.
the other 12 in front of him gelling and firing on all cylinders ,which is going to come sooner than later he will be a revelation in that position. Extend his contract now. We dont want to see him with Idris at Titans taking Campbells spot.